Bombay HC bars ex-directors from Solapur bank poll: appeal against supersession has no stay
Justice Abhay J. Mantri held that the petitioners sat on the board when the Section 88 enquiry began and that the 2018 supersession order stands, since the appeal against it is neither decided nor stayed.
Former directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank who resigned in 2018 will stay out of its next board election. On 16 November the Bombay High Court dismissed their petitions, because the order superseding their board has been neither stayed nor set aside, and they were on that board when the enquiry began.
Justice Abhay J. Mantri, sitting as the vacation court at the Kolhapur Circuit Bench and hearing the matter through video conferencing, found no illegality or perversity in the rejection of their nominations. He also declined to direct the appellate authority to decide the long-pending appeal within a fixed time.
Nominations rejected on 3 November
Nine writ petitions, numbered 5971 to 5979 of 2026, were heard together because the issue in each was identical. The lead petition, No. 5976, was filed by Sanjay Vitthalrao Shinde, an agriculturist from Madha taluka in Solapur district.
Each petitioner is a former director, chairman or member of the bank. Each filed a nomination in Form No. 4 for the board election programme covering 2026-27 to 2031-32.
The Returning Officer rejected the forms on 3 November. He held that the petitioners had been held responsible under Section 88 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, which disqualifies them under Section 73CA.
He also relied on the supersession of the board by an order of 28 May 2018. The Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Pune, dismissed the petitioners’ appeals on 6 November, and they came to the High Court.
The 2018 enquiry and supersession
The court recorded that the petitioners were members, directors or chairman of the board from 2009 to 2014 and again from 2014 until their resignations in 2018. A preliminary enquiry report under Section 83 was submitted on 3 February 2018.
On 18 April 2018 proceedings under Section 88 and Rule 72 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules began. On 28 May 2018 the Commissioner for Co-operation and Registrar of Co-operative Societies superseded the board under Section 110-A(1)(iii) and appointed an Administrator.
That order is under challenge before the Appellate Authority. The court noted that the authority has neither stayed it nor decided the appeal.
Resignation, and a March 2025 order
Mr Girish Godbole, Senior Counsel for Mr Shinde, argued that his client resigned on 15 May 2018, before the enquiry concluded. The supersession order, he said, could not apply to him as a member of the superseded board.
He leaned on an earlier order of 6 March 2025 in Writ Petition No. 2347 of 2025. That order asked the Appellate Authority to decide the appeal or the stay application expeditiously, preferably within two months, and barred coercive action under an order of 8 October 2024 until then.
Read purposively, he submitted, that order meant the Section 88 consequences should not block the election. In the alternative, the authority’s failure to comply should not hurt the petitioner, and he asked leave to amend the petition to seek a decision within two days.
Mr Godbole accepted, on a query from the court, that the 28 May 2018 order is sub judice before the Appellate Authority. Mr Abhijit Dilip Kulkarni, for the other petitioners, adopted the arguments and added that his clients resigned before the enquiry concluded and cannot be blamed for the alleged scam.
The petitioners cited Prakash Mahadeo Khot, Dilip Abhaykumar Phade, Mool Chand Yadav and Kalabharati Advertising. They argued that authorities cannot flout court orders, and that a pending appeal should come with an order staying or suspending the impugned decision.
The appeal hearing had ended in August 2026, they said, and the silence since suggested the matter was being kept pending for an ulterior purpose.
What the bank, State and rivals said
Mr Bhushan Walimbe, for the bank, said the nominations failed on two grounds: the petitioners were held responsible in the Section 88 enquiry, and as board members at the time of supersession they were barred by Section 73CA(3A). He added that the March 2025 order had expressly expressed no opinion on the merits.
Ms Tejas Kapre, Assistant Government Pleader, said the no-coercive-action direction concerned recovery proceedings and could not be equated with disqualification under Section 73CA. The enquiry, she said, was not a formality: 34 persons were exonerated, and it revealed a scam involving Rs 238 crore.
Mr Ajinkya Sangittrao, for the private respondents, argued that a pending appeal does not absolve the petitioners. He also pointed to the alternative remedy of an election petition under Section 77A of the Act.
Two provisions and an undisputed fact
Justice Mantri set out two provisions. Section 73CA(1)(f)(iii) disqualifies a person held responsible under Section 79 or 88, or held responsible for the costs of an enquiry under Section 85.
Section 73CA(3A) applies to an insured co-operative bank whose committee is superseded under Section 110A on the requisition of the Reserve Bank of India. No member of that committee is then eligible for re-election or fresh nomination to the bank’s committee for two terms from the date of supersession.
The court called it undisputed that the petitioners were committee members from 2009 to 2018, and that the Section 88 enquiry began during that period. The supersession order, it said, was passed while they sat on the board and is still under challenge, without a stay.
On resignation, the court noted that the petitioners had failed, on a query, to show that the competent authority accepted their resignations or that they were not board members when the enquiry began. Both the Returning Officer and the Registrar, it held, had acted correctly. The court said:
“I do not find any illegality or perversity in the impugned orders” (para 20)
No fresh deadline for the appeal
The court found no substance in the argument that the pending appeals, argued in August 2026, should not stand in the petitioners’ way. It likewise rejected the reading of paragraphs 7 and 8 of the March 2025 order that would shield them from the Section 88 consequences.
Nor did it consider it necessary to direct the Appellate Authority, once again, to decide the appeal within a time-bound period.
On the petitioners’ precedents, the court said the facts of this case were distinct and the law laid down in them was of hardly any assistance. The judgment does not discuss the objection that an election petition under Section 77A was available.
Order
The writ petitions are dismissed, with no order as to costs. The Rule, which had been made returnable forthwith and heard finally with the consent of counsel, is discharged.
The nominations of the petitioners stand rejected, and the court issued no direction to the Appellate Authority on the pending appeal against the 28 May 2018 supersession order.