Calcutta HC orders Bengal to review Abhishek Banerjee security in two weeks, Z+ not restored
Justice Krishna Rao noted that no Review Committee had met when the Z+ cover was cut to X on 12 May and that the State did not deny the later incidents, but left the threat assessment to the authorities.
A Member of Parliament’s Z+ security was cut to X category on 12 May, before any Review Committee met. The Calcutta High Court noted on 17 November that the committee confirmed the cut only on 29 May. It also noted that the State had not denied the incidents he reported from 30 May.
Justice Krishna Rao did not restore the Z+ cover. He disposed of Abhishek Banerjee’s writ petition by directing the West Bengal Home and Hill Affairs Department to convene a Review Committee within two weeks and weigh those incidents.
A decade on Z+, cut on 12 May
Mr Banerjee is a sitting Member of Parliament from Diamond Harbour and General Secretary of the All India Trinamool Congress. He was elected to the Lok Sabha in 2014, and again in 2019 and 2024.
His security was raised step by step. He had Y category cover in 2013, Y+ in 2014, Z in 2015 and Z+ in 2016. He held Z+ until 12 May 2026, when it was reduced to X category.
The petition challenged that decision as arbitrary, unreasonable and disproportionate. The hearing concluded on 12 November and judgment was delivered on 17 November.
The incidents the petitioner reported
Mr Shoaib Alam, Senior Advocate for the petitioner, said no fresh and objective threat assessment preceded the withdrawal on 12 May. He then listed what followed.
On 30 May, he said, a mob of about 500 people hurled eggs, stones, bricks and shoes at Mr Banerjee near Kamrabad More in Sonarpur, and he was injured. He had given the authorities notice of the visit on 29 May.
On 19 June, he said, 25 to 30 people attacked Mr Banerjee at the arrival gate of Kolkata airport. A complaint was made to the police, but no case was registered on it.
On 18 and 19 July a mob entered his constituency office and vandalised and looted party records, furniture and electronic items. On 3 September, 15 masked people entered his Camac Street office and destroyed the CCTV server. Both were reported to the police, he said, without action.
On 26 September Mr Banerjee made a representation for restoration of Z+ cover. The same day, Mr Alam said, the police kiosks outside his residence were removed.
On 7 November, during the pendency of the petition, a group hurled stones, eggs and bricks at his party workers and others attacked them with sticks and bamboos fitted with nails. The police registered a case on that complaint.
He added that on 5 October the Ministry of Home Affairs asked the State to provide adequate security on the basis of local threat perception.
Precedents for the petitioner
Mr Alam relied on a Patna High Court decision, Rajesh Ranjan v Union of India (2026 SCC OnLine Pat 2232), for the proposition that an order affecting a person’s rights must be reasoned and show application of mind.
He cited Naresh Agarwal v State of UP (2012 SCC OnLine All 264) on the government’s duty to exercise discretion fairly. He also cited a coordinate bench order of 10 April 2023 in Pankaj Kumar Gupta v State of West Bengal, which directed that withdrawn security be restored.
He added the Supreme Court’s decision in SP Kapoor v State of Himachal Pradesh ((1981) 4 SCC 716) on the post-haste manner in which an action was pushed through.
What the State and the Union said
Mr Billwadal Bhattacharyya, Additional Advocate General, said Mr Banerjee had no right to Z+ cover. A sitting Member of Parliament was entitled to X category cover, he argued, and the petitioner had been enjoying Z+ although there was no threat perception.
On 12 May, he said, the Joint Commissioner of Police (Security), Kolkata, assessed the threat and considered a Special Branch report before asking for the change. The Director, Security, West Bengal, then re-categorised the cover.
A Review Committee for protected persons met on 29 May, he said, and held that the petitioner should have X category cover. When the Home Ministry’s letter arrived, the State sent it to the Kolkata Police for a field-level threat assessment.
The police found no specific or actionable threat input that would justify moving back to Z+. The State said X cover had been provided strictly under the guidelines in the Yellow Book.
He relied on two Delhi High Court rulings. Ashwini Kumar Chopra v Union of India (2010 SCC OnLine Del 4470) held that security cover is a matter for the agencies concerned.
Ravi Kumar Rai v Union of India (decided on 11 August 2021) held that a court should not sit in appeal over a perception of threat.
Mr Dhiraj Kumar Trivedi, Additional Solicitor General, appeared for the Union. He said providing security to a Member of Parliament is the State’s duty, and that the Ministry had asked the State to consider the request but had not recommended Z+.
No Review Committee on 12 May
Justice Rao began with the record of the cut. On 12 May the Joint Commissioner of Police wrote to the Director, Security, that a local Special Branch assessment found no input indicating a specific threat to the petitioner from any outfit, organisation or person.
On that proposal the Director re-categorised the cover as X, with immediate effect and as an interim measure, and asked for the threat perception to be reviewed.
The court said it was admitted that no Review Committee meeting for re-categorisation had been held at that time. Of the report the State’s counsel filed in court, the judgment says there was:
“no document disclosed to show what are the reports considered” (para 18)
The Review Committee met on 29 May, by which time the Director had already changed the category. The meeting confirmed the change.
The State’s own report, the court noted, says such a committee, with representatives of the Special Branch, the Subsidiary Intelligence Bureau, the Home and Hill Affairs Department and the police administration, is mandated to evaluate security at least once every six months.
Incidents after 29 May went unanswered
The court then turned to what happened after the re-categorisation. Several incidents were reported between 30 May and 7 November, it said, and the State authorities had not denied them.
Each incident had been reported to the police. Of six incidents, the police registered a case in two, and both were under investigation.
The State’s report did not show that, after those complaints and the representation seeking an upgrade from X to Z+, the authorities had taken any step to consider the request.
On the incidents after 29 May, the court observed, the State had filed no report at all.
Where the court drew the line
Justice Rao said it was settled that a court does not exercise judicial review by sitting in appeal over the authority’s view on whether there is a threat. He did not decide whether Mr Banerjee needs Z+ cover.
He said the question for the authorities was different. Having been told of the incidents and asked to enhance the cover, they had not considered them. The court said:
“the authority should conduct a Review Meeting” (para 23)
The judgment does not discuss the decisions the parties cited.
Order
The petition is disposed of. The Principal Secretary, Home and Hill Affairs Department, Government of West Bengal, must convene the Review Committee meeting on re-categorisation of the petitioner’s security within two weeks of receiving the order.
The committee must take into account the incidents the petitioner reported to the authorities from 30 May to 7 November 2026, and pass an appropriate order in accordance with law.
The court made no other direction. The parties may act on a server copy of the judgment from the court’s website.