Justice A. Banerjee Justice A.S. Ray Calcutta HC TERM RESTORED Suspended without reasons, termrestored
[ Calcutta High Court ]

Shut for the 2019 poll, never reopened: Calcutta HC gives liquor licensees their unexpired term

A Division Bench held that the State could not keep temporary liquor licences suspended after the election without giving reasons, and that it could not then plead expiry by efflux of time. The licensees may trade from 15 December 2026, but the court did not strike down the notifications.

Temporary liquor licences granted for six months were suspended on 2 March 2019 because of the general election. The election ended on 23 May 2019. The licences never came back, and in December 2019 the State scrapped the licence category altogether.

On 13 November the Calcutta High Court held that this was unjust and unconscionable. A Division Bench of Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray directed West Bengal to let the licensees run their shops from 15 December 2026 for the balance of their six-month term.

Justice Apurba Sinha Ray wrote the judgment, and Justice Banerjee agreed. Three appeals, MAT 812 of 2024, MAT 847 of 2022 and MAT 418 of 2023, were decided together. The judgment was reserved on 6 October 2026.

A new licence category and an election

On 3 October 2018 the State introduced a new category of excise licence under Rule 4(q) of the 2003 excise rules for selecting new sites. It allowed sale of all kinds of liquor except tari and pachwai from a liquor shop. The appellants received temporary licences for six months.

On 2 March 2019 the Excise Commissioner issued Order No. C-40E suspending all such shops until further orders, citing the general election and the Election Commission’s instructions. The appellants say it was not based on any breach on their part.

The election ended on 23 May 2019, but the suspension continued. For the first group of appellants, whose licences were due to expire on 14 August 2019, that meant moving the High Court in W.P. No. 16265(W) of 2019.

On 22 August 2019 the Excise Commissioner rescinded the March order. The appellants were still not allowed to reopen. The order said continuation of the licences would be considered by the Excise Directorate on demand and supply, law and order and other factors.

Three writ dismissals, three appeals

Many similar petitions were decided by a common judgment of 27 September 2019. W.P. No. 16265(W) of 2019 was not part of that batch and was disposed of on 16 April 2024 by following it. That order is challenged in MAT 812 of 2024.

MAT 847 of 2022 challenges the dismissal of W.P. No. 1090 of 2020 on 16 September 2021, which followed Single Judge orders of 9 and 13 September 2021 in another petition. MAT 418 of 2023 challenges the dismissal of WPA No. 7930 of 2020, Goutam Mondal and others, on 8 October 2021.

In MAT 418 the appellants add a second grievance. While the Excise Commissioner was still considering their licences, Notification No. 2067-F.T. of 27 December 2019 omitted the licence category. They said the State used Sections 85 and 86 of the Bengal Excise Act, 1909 without invoking Sections 30, 31 and 37A.

The appeals raised a long list of issues. In the first two they included whether Sections 26 and 42 of the 1909 Act authorised the suspension and whether the election closure rules of 1998 allowed it beyond the period they contemplated.

In MAT 418 there were eleven, including vested rights, Article 14 and the later Notification 193-F.T. of 11 February 2022.

MAT 418 also raised a grievance about proceedings in which punishment or contempt was allegedly imposed on the appellants. They said it rested on an earlier order that was itself wrong and under challenge.

The court recorded the crux of the dispute:

“The crux of the dispute relates to the validity of the suspension of the appellants’ Rule 4(q) licence during the 2019 General Election and the refusal to restore the licences for their unexpired period after the suspension order was rescinded.” (para 11)

What the licensees argued

Senior Advocate Aninda Kr. Mitra, for the appellants, said a temporary licensee must spend heavily on infrastructure in the expectation of a regular licence. He cited the Calcutta ruling Sudhamoy Mondal v. Collector of Bankura and relied on the doctrine of legitimate expectation.

He said that, on State of Jharkhand v. Brahmaputra Metallics, an expectation is not a right in itself but failing to weigh it can make a decision arbitrary. He also cited State of M.P. v. Nandlal Jaiswal.

Section 42 of the 1909 Act, he said, gave the Excise Commissioner no power to suspend, and an election is no ground for suspending a licence. Only the Collector could do that. The appellants, he added, claim legal rights of renewal, not a fundamental right to trade in liquor.

The appellants also said licences in other categories stayed open while theirs was scrapped. They raised Articles 14, 19(1)(g) and 21 and said no reasons were recorded. They also complained that their representations of 8 August 2019 and 25 October 2021 were not considered.

The State: liquor trade and efflux of time

Advocate Shiv Sankar Banerjee, for the State, said liquor trade is res extra commercium and no citizen has a fundamental right to the grant, renewal or continuation of a licence. Section 37 of the Act allows a retail licence for a period not exceeding six months, so these had expired by efflux of time.

He said Section 42 gives the licensing authority a plenary power to cancel or suspend, and Section 26 lets a District Magistrate or Sub-Divisional Magistrate close shops to preserve public peace. There can be no promissory estoppel against the exercise of statutory power, he added.

He cited Kandath Distilleries, Khoday Distilleries, Ram Kumar, Six Holiday Resorts, Dipak Babaria, Nandlal Jaiswal and Kerala Bar Hotels.

No right to trade, but reasons owed

The court first accepted the State’s starting point. The appellants have no fundamental right to carry on a liquor business. But the privilege or legal right, whatever it is, “cannot be curtailed without showing any cogent ground” (para 32).

The court then looked at who suspended the licences. Section 42 lets the authority that granted a licence cancel or suspend it. The temporary licences, the court noted, were granted by the Collector of Nadia, so the Collector could suspend them.

The Excise Commissioner has certain powers under the Act, the court said, but the March 2019 order named no provision or rule behind the suspension. Dry days for public peace are possible. It was unclear, however, why licences stayed suspended after the election was over.

Reasons owed for an indefinite suspension

The State may cancel or suspend temporary licences, the court said, but if it suspends them for an indefinite period it must disclose reasons. The 22 August 2019 order gave none for the prolonged suspension. The licences, issued for six months, were suspended within days and kept suspended long after the poll.

The appellants had invested heavily and bought stocks of wine and foreign liquor. The State should have considered their position as businessmen, the court said, and should have disclosed reasons for the long suspension.

The Single Judge in the 9 September 2021 order had said the suspension was for public health and similar reasons. No order from the State authorities reflected any such reason. The court agreed with the appellants that “the Court cannot supplant reasons in favour of the State authorities” (para 33).

Nor did the State show any default on the appellants’ part. The Act and Rules, the court said, are specific about when temporary licences may be suspended or cancelled.

The judgment does not separately decide the validity of the notifications, the Article 14 challenge or the punishment proceedings. Its reasoning rests on the suspension and the refusal to revive the licences.

A promised decision, then a notification

The 22 August 2019 order had said the Excise Commissioner would take a concrete decision within 10 weeks. While that was pending, Notifications 2067-F.T. and 2068-F.T. of 27 December 2019 withdrew the Rule 4(q) category. It ceased to exist from that date.

But the appellants’ temporary licences, the court noted, were neither cancelled nor revived. The State could not argue that they had expired by efflux of time without giving the appellants the chance to run their businesses for the stipulated period.

Accepting that argument, it said, would put arbitrariness ahead of the lawful actions of individuals. The State has absolute rights, but they must be exercised with fairness and reasonableness. It added that the Single Judges, and the coordinate Bench that decided the batch on 27 September 2019, were not properly assisted on these points.

Order

The court directed the State to allow the appellants to run their businesses for the balance of their six-month temporary licences so that they can clear piled-up stock. They may trade from 15 December 2026 until the balance period is complete.

The appellants may apply under Rule 9(1)-F of the 2003 rules, and the State must decide any such application in accordance with law within three months. Their pending representations, particularly that of Goutam Mondal and others, must also be decided within three months.

Notifications 2067-F.T. and 2068-F.T. of 27 December 2019 are kept in abeyance until the balance licence period ends, and only for the appellants in the three appeals. The appeals are disposed of with no costs.