Justice A.K. Gupta Calcutta HC FIR QUASHED Affair alone is not 498A cruelty
[ Calcutta High Court ]

Calcutta HC quashes 498A case filed 28 years after remarriage: an affair alone is not cruelty

Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta found the FIR and the sons statements vague, with no date, time or manner of cruelty, and held the case fell within three Bhajan Lal categories.

A woman whose first marriage to a man was declared void by a civil court in 1988 married him again in 1992. In October 2020, nearly 28 years later, she lodged a Section 498A complaint against him. On 16 November the Calcutta High Court quashed it.

Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta held that the complaint rested on the husband’s relationship with another woman and the transfer of his properties to her. That, without a specific act of cruelty, did not make out the offence.

A void marriage and a second wedding

Mahinder Singh Sekhon was about 69 when his wife lodged a written complaint on 19 October 2020. The Ekbalpore police registered Case No 365 of 2020 on 25 October 2020 under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code.

She said they married at a Gurudwara in Behala, Kolkata, on 3 January 1983. On 16 August 1987 she learnt, she said, that he had concealed an affair with a woman from Ludhiana, Punjab, and that the two had a son.

She sued for a declaration that the marriage was null. On 29 June 1988 the Assistant District Judge at Alipore declared that no marriage had been solemnised on 3 January 1983, and that the marriage certificate was void.

According to the complaint, the husband then apologised to her parents, took shelter in their house when he fell ill with tuberculosis, and promised to end the relationship. She resumed living with him. A son was born on 2 June 1990 and the couple married again on 2 December 1992.

She later learnt that the other woman had given birth to a second child on 11 June 1990. Confronted, the husband denied it, the complaint says. A second son was born to the couple on 18 January 1995.

What she said went wrong after 2015

The couple lived together until 2015 with barely any friction, the complaint says. On 13 June 2014 he gave her a General Power of Attorney to sell or transfer half of his property at Argori in Howrah district.

From 2015 his behaviour changed. In 2016 she fractured her right hand in an accident and had two major surgeries, and he gave no financial or emotional support, she said.

In 2018 she learnt that he had settled in Ludhiana with the other woman. She filed a petition under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, MAT Suit No 3364 of 2018, for restitution of conjugal rights.

In 2019 she learnt that he had transferred all his immovable properties, including agricultural land in Punjab, to the other woman. Police filed Charge Sheet No 388 of 2021 on 31 December 2021, and the Chief Judicial Magistrate at Alipore took cognizance on 29 January 2022.

The husband’s case

Mr Sekhar Kumar Basu, Senior Advocate for the petitioner, argued that the FIR disclosed none of the ingredients of Section 498A. The allegations, he said, were mainly about an extra-marital affair.

He told the court that the petitioner had an earlier wife, under a registered marriage of 9 April 1978, and two sons from it. The wife in this case, he said, began pressing him to transfer all his property to her and her sons alone, which he refused.

He said the petitioner had always supported the family, including while working in Africa from 2014 to 2016, when he transferred money digitally for the sons’ education and maintenance. He had also bought properties in her name, Mr Basu said.

The complaint came 37 years after the first marriage and 28 years after the second, he argued, and both parties are now septuagenarians. He relied on two Supreme Court decisions, Pinakin Mahipatray Rawal v State of Gujarat ((2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 801) and Wasim v State (NCT of Delhi) ((2019) 3 SCC (Cri) 69).

Complainant and State: a trial is needed

Mr Debabrata Acharyya, for the wife, argued that the petitioner tortured and neglected her and the sons while hiding his relationship. She held back from lodging an FIR, he said, hoping things would improve, and acted only when they got worse after she raised the issue.

Mr Sagar Saha, for the State, produced the case diary. He said the FIR disclosed a cognizable offence and that the statements recorded under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure made out a prima facie case. Mr Acharyya added that the court should not weigh the material without a full trial.

No act of cruelty in the FIR

Justice Gupta began with what the complaint actually alleged. Its principal allegation, he said, was that the petitioner had carried on a relationship with another woman from the start of the marriage.

The court recorded that the marriage certificate on file showed an earlier marriage on 9 April 1978, before the complainant’s first marriage to him. She also married him again in 1992 knowing of the relationship, and she accepted that he lived in Punjab most of the time.

She had also filed a similar complaint before the Punjab police on similar facts, the court noted, but it could not be initiated after a preliminary inquiry.

The FIR, the court said, made no specific allegation of physical or mental torture. It found no single instance of abuse or assault on her, and no material from the investigation corroborating such claims. The court called the allegations:

“general, omnibus and lacking in particulars” (para 20)

The two sons had told the police under Section 161 that their father sometimes abused their mother and assaulted her from time to time. The court found no such allegation in the complaint, “in a single word”, and no specific role or detail in the witnesses’ statements.

Where the court drew the line

The court accepted that an FIR need not be an encyclopaedia of every detail. Even so, it said, the FIR gave no date, time or manner of the alleged torture. A case lodged after 28 years of marriage without particulars did not constitute an offence under Section 498A.

Justice Gupta found the allegations vague and omnibus, made only to harass a man now in his seventies with an ulterior motive. Continuing the case, he held, would be a sheer abuse of the process of law.

He then turned to the two Supreme Court decisions the petitioner had cited. In Pinakin Mahipatray Rawal, a husband had been convicted under Sections 498A and 306 after his wife’s suicide, on a case resting entirely on an alleged relationship with a colleague.

The Supreme Court, the High Court recorded, had held that developing intimacy with another person and failing in marital obligations is not by itself cruelty. To fall within the Explanation to Section 498A the conduct must be likely to drive the spouse to suicide, though mental harassment can also be cruelty.

In Wasim, the husband was convicted for mental cruelty from an extra-marital relationship and threats to leave his wife. The Supreme Court set the conviction aside, holding that cruelty under Section 498A has two limbs, wilful conduct likely to drive a woman to suicide or cause grave injury, or harassment linked to an unlawful demand for property.

The High Court drew one principle from the two. An extra-marital relationship without more is not cruelty, and the prosecution must prove conduct within clause (a) or harassment within clause (b) of the Explanation. Here the FIR confined itself to the relationship and the property transfers, which fell within neither limb.

Bhajan Lal categories and the outcome

The court looked at the case diary and found no sufficient or cogent material against the petitioner. Even if the case went on, it said, his conviction appeared bleak and remote.

The court held that the case fell within Categories 1, 3 and 7 of the guidelines in State of Haryana v Bhajan Lal (1992 Supp (1) SCC 33). It exercised the inherent power under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to quash.

Order

The revisional application, CRR 2178 of 2022, is allowed. Ekbalpore Police Station Case No 365 of 2020 under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code is quashed, with all proceedings before the 9th Court of the Judicial Magistrate at Alipore.

The order of 29 January 2022 of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Alipore, taking cognizance on Charge Sheet No 388 of 2021, is also set aside. Both orders operate only as far as the petitioner is concerned.

Pending applications are disposed of and any interim order stands vacated. A copy of the judgment goes to the trial court, the case diary is returned to the State’s counsel, and the parties are to act on the server copy from the court’s website.