Calcutta HC denies work order to top dredging bidder, orders security back with 12% interest
Justice Krishna Rao held that no agreement or work order existed when the Irrigation Department moved from volume sharing to revenue sharing, and distinguished the Supreme Court ruling in Mihan India.
Rajia Engineering won the auction for a 15.90 km river-dredging job with a bid of Rs 5,86,58,035. It was given a letter of acceptance on 15 March 2026 and lodged its security two days later. Eight months on, it had no work order.
On 16 November the Calcutta High Court said it could not direct one. Justice Krishna Rao held that the State had taken a conscious policy decision to change the dredging model before any agreement was signed. He ordered the security returned within one month, with 12 per cent interest from 17 March.
A bid, an acceptance and a security deposit
The Irrigation and Waterways Department of the West Bengal Government invited proposals for dredging, de-silting and removal of river bed material from the New Cossey River. A first tender was issued on an expert body’s recommendation. The department then found that the stretch overlapped some sand blocks auctioned by the West Bengal Mineral Development and Trading Corporation Limited.
It issued a fresh request for proposal that kept the dredging site away from the sand mining blocks. Rajia Engineering bid and ranked first at Rs 5,86,58,035. The letter of acceptance covered the stretch from Tituan to Shyampur.
The company was asked to meet the Executive Engineer, West Midnapore Division, and sign the agreement set out in the proposal. It was to furnish performance security of Rs 29,33,035 and additional performance security of Rs 1,17,32,139, the latter as a bank guarantee.
Both were submitted on 17 March 2026. The court recorded that none of this was in dispute.
The petitioner’s case: a concluded contract
Mr Sk Md Galib, appearing for the petitioner, said the authorities had given no reason for withholding the work order despite repeated requests.
The letter of acceptance allows only 18 months to complete the work, he said, and that deadline cannot be met without a work order.
He told the court that a public interest petition, numbered 287 of 2026, challenged the issue of multiple proposals for this stretch in Debra block, Paschim Medinipur.
The petitioner intervened, he said, and a Division Bench refused any interim order and directed an exchange of affidavits.
Even so, he said, the authorities kept the work order back. No decision to cancel had been taken, he argued.
He relied on Mihan India Limited v GMR Airports Limited ((2022) 19 SCC 69) for the proposition that a letter of acceptance followed by acceptance of performance security makes a concluded contract. He also cited Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour v Chief Executive Officer ((2024) 15 SCC 461), and the Supreme Court’s decision in Shishir Realty ((2022) 16 SCC 527).
The State: a new dredging model
Mr Rivu Dutta, appearing for the State, said the letter of acceptance was indeed issued, but the department was then examining a revised mechanism for dredging. With the concurrence of the Finance Department it decided to adopt a “Revenue Sharing Method” in place of the earlier “Volume Sharing Method”, particularly for dredging done for flood management.
He traced the steps. A letter of 9 June 2026 said all such dredging should henceforth go through an e-auction on the revenue sharing method, at no cost to the State. On 3 August 2026 the competent authority directed that issue of work orders be withheld until further order.
On 3 September 2026 the department decided in principle to cancel the identified ongoing works under the volume sharing method and process the balance work under the revenue sharing method. The petitioner’s work was one for which no work order had been issued.
Mr Dutta also relied on Subodh Kumar. If the State thinks it necessary to alter or cancel a contract because of public interest or a change in policy, he said, that consideration should be treated as bona fide.
What the 3 September order said
The State filed a report with the order of 3 September, issued by the Secretary-in-Charge of the department with the Finance Department’s concurrence. The judgment reproduces it in full.
Under volume sharing, the order said, the department has no stackyard for its share of the dredged material. Part of that share is used to repair embankments, and the rest is left for the contractor to buy at a rate per unit volume.
The order said left-out material could slide back onto the river bed in heavy rain, and that pilferage from unguarded stacks was almost unavoidable. Under revenue sharing, the dredging agency takes away nearly all the material and pays a revenue per unit volume, plus royalty, cess and other taxes.
Recent e-auctions on the revenue model had shown a much higher potential for revenue, the order said. The State was making a huge loss under volume sharing, which it called against public interest.
It therefore decided in principle to cancel all 59 ongoing volume-sharing works and re-auction the balance of each under the new method. It cited clauses 11.1.1(b) (poor performance) and 11.1.1(i) (loss of public interest) of the tender document. Earnest money and performance security were to be refunded to each agency without punitive action.
Why Mihan India did not help
The judge noted the department’s own account of the scale. Dredging by the Mineral Development Corporation, the Irrigation and Waterways Directorate and district administrations was then under way at 81 locations over 625 km, on a volume of about 5.30 crore cubic metres.
Justice Rao reproduced long passages from Mihan India and from Shishir Realty. The first dealt with a letter of acceptance after which annulment of bidding was held arbitrary, and the second with the State’s claim of loss as a reason to walk out of a bargain.
He then held both rulings distinguishable. Here, the authorities had re-examined the matter after the letter of acceptance but before the work order was issued and before any agreement was executed.
The judge also reproduced the Supreme Court’s caution in Subodh Kumar: the State may alter or cancel a contract on public interest or policy grounds, but those considerations must be bona fide and earnestly reflected in the decision-making and the final decision.
A conscious policy decision
On the facts, the court found that the proposal was processed on the volume sharing method. After the letter of acceptance, the authorities re-examined the matter and decided to adopt the revenue sharing method, by the order of 3 September 2026.
That, Justice Rao said, was a conscious policy decision. He added that no agreement had been entered with the petitioner and no work order issued, and that in the meantime the respondents had taken their policy decision. His conclusion was that:
“no order can be passed for issuance of work order” (para 25)
The petitioner had deposited its security on 17 March, the court said, but the policy had now changed and the work order was not being issued. The money therefore had to go back.
Order
The authorities must return the performance security of Rs 29,33,035 and the additional performance security of Rs 1,17,32,139 within one month of receiving the order. Interest at 12 per cent a year runs from 17 March 2026 until payment.
The writ petition is disposed of. Hearing concluded on 13 October 2026, and the judgment was delivered and uploaded on 16 November.
Parties may act on a server copy from the court’s website, and urgent certified copies may be issued on completion of formalities.