Delhi HC upholds Connaught Place eviction for a golf store: lapsed offer did not end the need
Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar refused leave to defend to two sets of tenants of shop E-18, holding that a sister share claim, unmentioned suits and a re-let neighbouring shop raised no triable issue.
A professional golfer with early-stage arthritis wants to swap coaching for a golf equipment store at E-18, Connaught Place. His tenants, two branches of the Goyal family who run the shops “Ashoks” and “Vintage”, said the plan was invented. On 18 November the Delhi High Court upheld the eviction order and refused them leave to defend.
Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar dismissed both revision petitions. He held that the tenants had pointed to no fact that, if proved, would stop the landlords from recovering the ground and mezzanine floors.
A family tenancy of several decades
The shop was let long ago to a partnership, M/s Om Prakash Surendra Kumar. After the original partners died, Ashok Goyal took one portion and Rahul Goyal and Gaurav Goyal the other.
The landlords, Ajay Gupta and Sanjay Gupta, trace their title to a perpetual lease of 4 January 1926 and a partition decree of 2 November 1964. They became co-owners on the death of their father, Y.N. Gupta, on 12 January 2019, under a will of 28 January 2016.
Their sister, Anjali Vaid, has a partition suit pending, CS(OS) 231/2019, in which the will is challenged. On 5 April 2019 she wrote to the tenants claiming a one-fifth share and asking for rent.
A golf store, a lapsed offer
The landlords filed for eviction under Section 14(1)(e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act in September 2021. They said the first landlord needed the premises for a retail store of golfing gear, on an offer he had received that was to be formalised by 30 September 2021.
The tenants applied for leave to defend on 4 October 2021. The Additional Rent Controller dismissed those applications as late on 12 February 2025, but the High Court set that order aside with the landlords’ consent on 28 March 2025 and sent the matter back.
Arguments ended on 19 January 2026. On 24 March 2026 the Controller again refused leave and ordered eviction, and a review petition failed on 11 July 2026.
What the tenants argued
Mr Abhimanyu Mahajan, Senior Advocate for Rahul and Gaurav Goyal, said the sister’s letter showed a co-owner opposed eviction. He relied on India Umbrella Manufacturing, (2004) 3 SCC 178, to argue the presumption of consent was displaced.
He said the landlords hid the partition suit and that the offer was unnamed, undated and from an undisclosed retailer. The medical record was dated March 2022, after the petition, he added.
On alternative accommodation, the tenants listed shops E-15 to E-17, E-19, E-21, E-22 to E-27, E-40, E-41 and E-44 to E-48. They pressed hardest on E-16, which had been let to Westwind Retails in November 2020 after a portion was recovered from another tenant for the late father’s need.
Counsel for Ashok Goyal added that the landlords had not disclosed a second suit, over modification of the 1964 decree. He also said the second landlord had relied on the pending partition suit in a different eviction case, so the landlords were taking inconsistent stands.
The landlords’ answer
Counsel for the landlords said every objection was considered in the Controller’s order or the review order, and revision cannot be used to reappraise them. The Act does not require a landlord to name his proposed business, she said, nor to start it.
Even if the will were ignored, she said, the sons would remain co-owners with their sisters and mother, and one co-owner can sue. She added that the tenants never showed that any portion of E-16 was vacant.
A narrow revisional lens
The judge began with the limits of his jurisdiction. He relied on Sarla Ahuja, Dilbahar Singh and Abid-Ul-Islam, all Supreme Court rulings, to say the power under Section 25-B(8) is supervisory and not appellate.
He tested every plea against one question: if proved, would it disentitle the landlords from an eviction order? He held that an order that fails to mention a plea is not vitiated if the plea raises no triable issue.
The sister’s letter
The judge accepted that one co-owner may sue and that consent of the others is presumed unless disagreement is shown. The question was whether the letter showed it.
He found it did not. It asserted a one-fifth share, sought rent and asked tenants not to alter the premises, but did not object to eviction. It was dated more than two years before the petition, and she was free to oppose at any time.
He also noted that landlords need only show a title better than the tenants, who named no one else as the landlord. In the judge’s words, the landlords
“were not required to establish an indefeasible or exclusive title” (para 75)
Suits left unmentioned
Non-disclosure matters in these summary proceedings, the judge said, but its consequence depends on the materiality of the omitted fact. The disputes over the will and the 1964 decree are between those claiming through Y.N. Gupta.
The partition suit was pleaded by the tenants themselves, so it was before the Controller. The second suit was raised only in written submissions. The tenants showed no hidden vacant premises and no prejudice.
Shop E-16 and the five-part test
The judge applied Lalta Prasad Gupta. A tenant who alleges unused alternative premises must plead the particulars, the landlord’s title, that the premises were vacant and available, how they suit the need, and how the landlord deprived himself of them.
The landlords had disclosed every property and why each was unavailable or unsuitable. The tenants named no vacant premises beyond a bare assertion, and the judge held the properties of the second landlord could not be used to meet the first landlord’s need.
E-16 was let in November 2020, ten months before the petition and before the pleaded need arose in 2021. The portion recovered earlier was for the late father, who used a wheelchair, and was let after his death with rent shared among his five heirs.
The Section 19 plea, he added, appeared first in written submissions. It gives a remedy to a dispossessed tenant and does not make E-16 available to the landlords.
Why the lapsed offer did not matter
The tenants said the requirement died when the offer to open the store lapsed on 30 September 2021. The judge disagreed. The requirement was the landlord’s wish to run a business of his own, and he held that the offer
“was only the occasion for, and the proposed mode of, carrying on that business” (para 98)
A landlord need not disclose the exact business, and cannot be held to start that very business once the premises are vacated. A prescription dated March 2022 did not show the pleaded condition was fabricated.
He distinguished Ved Prakash, decided after a full trial on a landlord who had hidden his properties, and Renu Mehta, where ownership was first denied and then admitted.
Inconsistent stands, and the review
The Controller’s order of 5 July 2024 in the second landlord’s own case on shop E-44 had treated the jointly owned properties as not available to him. The tenants said that was inconsistent with seeking E-18 now.
The judge held it was not. E-18 could never have been vacant accommodation in that case because the tenants were in it, and the two cases involve different landlords with different needs. The doctrine of approbation and reprobation did not apply, since the present petition was filed first.
The review order, he said, had simply declined to turn review into an appeal, and that approach could not be faulted.
Order
Both revision petitions are dismissed. The Controller’s order of 24 March 2026 and the review order of 11 July 2026 are upheld.
The petitions and pending applications are disposed of, and there is no order as to costs.