Justice S. Narula Delhi HC FRESH REVIEW Aid refused for all 100 hires
[ Delhi High Court ]

Delhi HC quashes blanket aid refusal for 100 Tamil school hires, but BEd alone will not qualify

Justice Sanjeev Narula held that the Directorate of Education could not reject all 100 appointments in one order, and told it to decide each case on its records within 12 weeks, while ruling that a BEd degree cannot replace the JBT or BTC training that aided schools require.

The Directorate of Education refused grant-in-aid for the salaries of all 100 people hired by seven Tamil minority schools in Delhi. On 17 November the Delhi High Court set that order aside, because objections of very different weight had been used to reject everyone together.

Justice Sanjeev Narula did not clear the hires either. He held that BEd graduates without the JBT or BTC training cannot count as qualified Assistant Teachers in aided schools, and he sent every appointment back for separate, reasoned scrutiny.

Seven schools, 95 per cent aid, 100 posts

The Delhi Tamil Education Association was set up in 1923 and registered on 14 March 1940. It runs seven government-aided minority schools with nearly 7,000 students and about 400 staff, and the Government pays 95 per cent of staff salaries.

Its minority status under Article 30(1) of the Constitution is not disputed. Two connected petitions reached the court: the Association’s own, W.P.(C) 14795/2025, and one by the employees, W.P.(C) 17099/2025, who wanted unpaid salaries, future pay and interest.

The court described the dispute in one sentence:

“The controversy thus raises questions concerning the management’s autonomy in making appointments, the statutory conditions governing the release of public funds and the liability to remunerate employees for services rendered.” (para 2)

Round one: the right to appoint

The dispute follows an earlier case. On 28 May 2024, in W.P.(C) 15276/2023, the court held that the Association could fill vacant posts of Principals and teachers without the Directorate’s prior approval.

A Division Bench affirmed that on 22 July 2024 in LPA 642/2024, binding the Association to its statement that it would comply strictly with Rule 96(3) of the Delhi School Education Rules, 1973. The Supreme Court dismissed the further challenge on 6 December 2024.

Those rulings did not look at the candidates’ qualifications or at their eligibility for grant-in-aid, the court said.

3,843 applications, 100 appointments

On 26 June 2024 the Association advertised 107 vacancies in three newspapers. It says it received 3,843 applications and filled 100 posts.

The 100 comprise four Principals, 42 Assistant Teachers, 35 other teaching staff, 12 clerical and laboratory employees, and seven Peons and Malis.

The Association sent the appointment files to the Directorate’s zonal offices in April and May 2025. On 23 September 2025 the court told the Directorate to list specific deficiencies, release aid for appointments with no discrepancy and decide the rest.

The Directorate raised its objections on 1 October 2025, and the Association replied on 8 October. On 4 November 2025 the Directorate rejected aid for all 100.

The employees say they joined on formal letters and were never paid. The court noted that their appointment letter of 16 January 2025 says salary will be paid only on receipt of grant-in-aid, and that it forfeits pay if an employee resigns during probation.

What each side argued

Mr Kartikeye Dang, for the Association, argued that the Directorate cannot use the aid process to impose restrictions it could not have placed at the recruitment stage. The Directorate had refused to nominate its representatives to the Selection Committees, he said, because it planned to challenge the earlier rulings, which were never stayed.

He relied on the 2022 Recruitment Rules, which recognise a BEd for Assistant Teachers, and said their later rescission could not change the criteria for a recruitment already under way. He added that direct recruitment to clerical posts was needed because no eligible staff were available for promotion.

Ms Diya Kapur, Senior Advocate, for the employees, backed the Association on the 2022 notification. She said Rule 98(4) deems an appointment approved if the Directorate does not disapprove it within 15 days, and that the dispute over aid cannot deprive staff of pay for work done.

Mrs Avnish Ahlawat, Standing Counsel for the Delhi Government, said minority status does not exempt appointments paid from public funds from statutory recruitment rules. The 2022 notification applied only to government schools, she argued, and a BEd is not equivalent to the elementary teacher training that the 1989 Rules require.

Autonomy to appoint, not to be funded

The court began with Article 30(1). The right to administer includes the freedom to appoint staff, and State aid does not dilute it, but it is not a right to maladminister, and the State may set qualifications and conditions for using grants.

It then separated two things. The management’s freedom to appoint without prior approval is different from whether an appointment is eligible for aid, and the department cannot use the second to take control of the first.

The second proviso to Rule 98(2) dispenses with approval in aided minority schools, the court said. It does not dispense with prescribed qualifications, a sanctioned vacancy or other binding requirements, and Rule 66(2) keeps an unqualified teacher’s pay out of the aid calculation.

It added a method: each objection must be tested against the legal requirement said to be breached and the consequence for breaching it. A defect in one appointment cannot sink the others unless the department shows the irregularity runs through them.

Why BEd graduates fell short

The Directorate objected to Assistant Teachers who held a BEd but not the JBT or BTC that the 1989 Recruitment Rules prescribe for aided schools. The Association relied on a 24 February 2022 notification that allowed a BEd route.

The court found that notification was issued under the proviso to Article 309 for recruitment to the Directorate’s own Assistant Teacher (Primary) posts. It superseded the 2013 Rules for that post and did not touch the 1989 Rules for aided schools.

It was withdrawn on 15 October 2024, after the vacancies were advertised and before the Selection Committee met on 23 November 2024. That did not help the Association, the court said, because Tej Prakash Pathak bars changing eligibility criteria midway but does not let a recruiter rely on rules that never governed the posts.

The court followed Divya Bhaskar, where it had read the same 1989 Rules to exclude a BEd-only candidate. It also cited Supreme Court rulings in PM Latha, Yogesh Kumar and Devesh Sharma that a BEd is not a higher qualification than teacher training at primary level.

The limited protection in Navin Kumar covers certain BEd candidates appointed before 11 August 2023. The Association began recruiting in 2024, so it did not apply.

The court also rejected the argument that a BEd is a higher training qualification allowing relaxation of the JBT or BTC rule. Under Rule 97, any relaxation needs the Director’s prior approval, and none was shown.

“B.Ed., without the prescribed JBT/BTC qualification, does not satisfy the essential training requirement” (para 24)

The figures were also muddled. The Association counted 39 BEd selections and three with JBT or BTC, while the Directorate referred in places to 43 appointments and 42 without the training. The court said the appointment schedules and merit sheet must settle the individual cases.

Principals, clerks and gardeners

On the four Principals, the court held that the Association need not exhaust promotion before direct recruitment, relying on the Division Bench ruling in St Anthony’s Girls Senior Secondary School. Autonomy to choose the head still does not remove the prescribed qualifications, experience and age.

On age, the Directorate cannot reject a Principal by citing only the old 45-year limit. It must consider Rule 104 and the 2023 notification setting 50 years for the corresponding government post.

On experience, the court applied B Ramakichenin and Santosh Pal Meena. Unless the rules say experience must follow the degree, earlier teaching cannot be excluded merely because it came before the degree.

An Assistant Professor’s college service, by contrast, is not automatically a substitute for the school experience the rules name. Each of these cases, the court said, needs a separate look at the records.

The same approach ran through the other teaching posts and Librarians, where the court asked the Directorate to verify actual degrees, subjects studied and recognition of the BEd programmes by the National Council for Teacher Education. It said verification by a university does not itself show that the programme was recognised in the relevant session.

For clerical posts, Rule 108 does not give a general preference to promotion, and the source of recruitment depends on the applicable rules. A departmental label of a post as non-selection cannot override them.

On the seven Peons and Malis, the Directorate said the posts were abolished or recruitment barred after the 6th Pay Commission. The court said the order of 4 November 2020 restricts committees for direct recruitment to Class-IV posts but does not show that every such post was abolished, and the department must name the legal instrument.

Committees, marks and notices

On the Selection Committees, the court held that where the Association sought nominees and gave the Directorate a fair chance, the department’s absence cannot invalidate a selection. The Deputy Director had told the Association on 3 October 2024 to keep recruitment in abeyance, though the earlier rulings were not stayed.

That did not excuse the Association’s own lapses. The Assistant Teacher committee of 23 November 2024 included the Principal of only the Lodi Estate school, and Rule 96(3)(b) requires the Head of each school. The Directorate must check compliance school by school.

On marking, the court relied on Kiran Jain: the State may set eligibility, but how an aided minority institution ranks eligible candidates is within Article 30(1). The Directorate may check whether the five-mark limit for interviews was exceeded, but cannot reassess merit.

The Committee’s minutes record 477 applications, 53 eligible candidates, 52 interviewed and 42 selected. Those numbers alone do not show a pre-determined selection, the court said, and 52 of the 53 shortlisted candidates attended, although the Directorate says notices went out only a day before.

The court also said that medical and police checks before appointment letters, certificates from outside Delhi and a lapse under the Employment Exchanges Act do not by themselves show a pre-determined selection or void appointments. A claim of manipulation needs specific evidence.

The Directorate also alleged breach of the 4 per cent disability reservation, and the court agreed minority status gives no exemption from it. But no cadre-wise calculation or roster was placed before the court, and a general allegation cannot justify rejecting all 100 appointments.

Deemed approval left open

Rule 98(3) requires particulars of each appointment to reach the Director within seven days, and Rule 98(4) deems an appointment approved if no disapproval follows within 15 days. The Association relied on communications of 16 November 2024 and 3 April 2025.

The court said their legal effect cannot be read from the dates alone. The mode, proof of receipt and any timely disapproval must be checked for each appointment, and a general notice of proposed recruitment is not communication of the names of persons selected.

It distinguished an earlier Association case where the Director’s nominees had signed the minutes and the particulars were admittedly received. Here, communication is itself disputed, and Rule 66(2) must be read alongside Rule 98(4), so deemed approval cannot by itself cure a missing qualification.

Order set aside, with a twelve-week schedule

The court said the order of 4 November 2025 treated objections of differing character and consequence as enough to reject all 100 appointments. It held that such a collective conclusion cannot be sustained:

“Such a collective conclusion cannot be sustained” (para 58)

It added that some individual objections may still justify refusing aid, and that the judgment neither validates every appointment nor creates an unconditional right to aid. The court did not itself choose between the rival compilations of records.

On pay, it said that working and hardship do not oblige the State to fund appointments that fail the statutory conditions. Relying on K Brahmanandam, it distinguished the State’s liability to fund appointments from the institution’s own liability to pay for services actually rendered.

The clauses in the appointment letters postponing salary until aid arrives cannot extinguish that liability, it held, and a stipulation on resignation cannot forfeit pay already earned. It declined a general award of arrears or interest because the amounts, periods and payments differ for each employee.

Order

The order of 4 November 2025 is set aside and both petitions are partly allowed. Within one week of the judgment the Director of Education must designate an officer not below Additional Director, who was not associated with the impugned decision, to examine the records afresh.

Within two weeks of the judgment the Association must file an indexed, employee-wise statement covering the school, post, vacancy, rules, qualifications, experience, dates, service and salary paid. It must also list the Rule 98(3) communications it relies on.

The officer then has two weeks to reconcile the statement with departmental records and issue a single deficiency statement. The Association has one week to respond.

Before upholding any objection, the officer must name the provision, the deficiency and the material, and give the Association and the employee a chance to respond, with a personal hearing where needed. The whole exercise must finish within twelve weeks, with a separate reasoned order for each employee, sent within three working days of issue.

Where aid is allowed, the Directorate must work out salary and arrears for the verified period and release its 95 per cent share within four weeks of the individual decision. The Association must deposit its share under Section 10(2) of the Delhi School Education Act.

Where aid is refused, that decision will not itself end the employment or the employee’s claim against the Association for pay for work done. The Association must give each such employee a statement of service and payments within four weeks and pay any undisputed amount.

The court did not decide the Association’s internal dispute over its competing office-bearers or the impleadment application, CM APPL 18976/2026. Pending applications stand disposed of.