Justice S.K. Sharma Delhi HC APPEAL DISMISSED A 2016 lease deed may be provedin a 2008 partition suit
[ Delhi High Court ]

Delhi HC lets brother call Sub-Registrar official to prove 2016 lease in 18-year-old suit

Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma held there was sufficient cause for leaving the official off the 2013 witness list, because the lease deed did not exist then. Whether the rented house is comparable stays open.

A man who sued his elder brother for a share of a Janakpuri house in 2008 will be allowed to call a Sub-Registrar’s official to prove a lease deed signed in 2016. On 19 November the Delhi High Court refused to disturb that order, rejecting the argument that the deed was a late addition to the evidence.

Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma dismissed the defendant’s appeal against an order of the Joint Registrar (Judicial) dated 17 November 2025. She left every question about what the lease deed proves for the trial court.

An 18-year-old suit over House A-1/49

The plaintiff, Umesh Kumar Sahni, sued in CS(OS) 1269/2008 for partition, rendition of accounts and a permanent injunction over House No. A-1/49, Janakpuri, New Delhi. The suit has been pending since 5 July 2008, and the defendant is his elder brother, Sushil Kumar Sahni.

The defendant says the plaintiff has no share, as he was a student living with the family when the leasehold was bought on 5 January 1980. He says he paid the price, with some help from another brother, Vinay Kumar Sahni, who filed his own suit that was clubbed for trial.

Issues were framed on 19 February 2010, and an issue on rendition of accounts was added on 1 December 2011. The plaintiff filed his witness list on 29 November 2013, naming six witnesses.

The Rs 10,000 order and the Division Bench

On 16 March 2017 the plaintiff applied for mesne profits and annexed a registered lease deed of 27 January 2016. It covered a different house, A-1/358 in Janakpuri, which the defendant describes as new, three-storeyed and on a 60-feet main road.

A judge of the High Court ordered Rs 10,000 a month on 2 May 2017. On 31 July 2018 a Division Bench modified that order, holding that the figure was not conclusive and that the defendant could lead evidence on mesne profits if the plaintiff succeeded.

The application to summon the official

After his cross-examination ended on 6 January 2023, the plaintiff filed I.A. 3612/2023 under Order XVI Rule 1(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure. He asked to summon an official of the Sub-Registrar-II B, Rajouri Garden, with the record of the lease deed.

The Joint Registrar allowed it on 17 November 2025. He noted that the plaintiff bore the onus on rendition of accounts, and said the defendant’s objections on relevance could be put to the witness in cross-examination.

What the defendant argued

The defendant argued that the official was not on the witness list and that the lease deed was not on the plaintiff’s list of documents. He said it had not been admitted or denied, and that it was being brought in about 15 years after the suit began.

He said the deed was between third parties and could be proved only through its executants. A Sub-Registrar’s official, he argued, has no personal knowledge of the contents.

On comparability, he said his house is about half a century old, in poor condition and on an internal lane. He also relied on Section 139 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, saying a person summoned only to produce a document cannot be cross-examined.

What the plaintiff said

The plaintiff’s counsel said the lease deed was registered on 3 February 2016, more than two years after the witness list was filed. The official could not have been named in 2013, he said.

He said the plaintiff claims Rs 30,000 a month as market rent because the defendant has exclusive possession. The official had been called to prove the deed’s existence, execution and registration, and his examination-in-chief was already recorded. He called the appeal a delaying tactic.

A deed that did not exist in 2013

Justice Sharma said Order XVI Rule 1(3) lets a party summon a witness not on the list, with the court’s leave and on sufficient cause. The deed itself, dated 27 January 2016, came into existence after the 2013 list was filed.

On that footing, she held that

“sufficient cause existed for not including the official witness in the original list” (para 16)

She also pointed out that a copy of the deed had been on the court file since 2017, with I.A. 3480/2017. The application, she said, was to prove a known document and not to bring in an entirely new one.

Comparability and Section 139

The defendant’s objection that the two houses are not comparable was not a reason to bar the evidence, the judge held. Whether the leased house matches the suit property in location, area and condition can be weighed when the evidence is appreciated.

The Division Bench had already left both sides free to lead evidence on mesne profits. The defendant can lead rebuttal evidence, and the court held the deed could not be called wholly irrelevant at this stage.

On Section 139, she said the provision covers a person summoned merely to produce a document. This official was summoned to prove existence, execution and registration, and had been examined as a witness, so the defendant could cross-examine him.

Order

The appeal was dismissed, with no infirmity found in the Joint Registrar’s order of 17 November 2025. The defendant may cross-examine the official within the scope of his testimony and may lead evidence in rebuttal.

Allowing the witness to prove the deed is not an acceptance of its contents, Justice Sharma said, nor a finding on the market rent or on any mesne profits owed. The court will examine the deed’s relevance and comparability at the appropriate stage, and the judgment was directed to be uploaded forthwith.