Gauhati HC dismisses 12-year-late challenge to foreigner opinion, doubting lawyer-fault plea
A Division Bench found that the Tribunal record showed the petitioner skipping hearings and ignoring two cost orders, and that he had collected documents long after the 2011 opinion while claiming he knew nothing of it.
A man from Morigaon, Assam, went to the Gauhati High Court 12 years and 7 months after a Foreigners Tribunal declared him a foreigner. He said his lawyer had failed him and that he learned of the opinion only in 2023. The High Court dismissed his petition on 16 November.
Justice Rajesh Mazumdar wrote the order for a Division Bench that also included Justice Kalyan Rai Surana. The bench held that the Tribunal’s own record contradicted the petitioner’s account, and left the opinion of 21 March 2011 undisturbed.
A 2011 opinion and a 2023 petition
On a reference by the Superintendent of Police (Border), Morigaon, the Foreigners Tribunal 1st, Morigaon, heard FT (D) Case No. 01/06. Its Member declared the petitioner, on 21 March 2011, a foreigner under the Foreigners Act, 1946 who had illegally entered Assam on or after 25 March 1971.
The petitioner filed his writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution on 1 December 2023. The respondents included the Union of India, the Morigaon police and district administration, the Election Commission of India and the Assam State Coordinator of NRC.
What the Tribunal had recorded in 2011
The petitioner received summons on 16 September 2006. He first appeared, with a lawyer, on 6 July 2009 and filed a written statement denying the allegations about his citizenship.
From 19 April 2010 he stayed away, taking adjournments. The Tribunal said he made no attempt to prove or exhibit any document through formal evidence. He had only filed photocopies of some documents with his written statement.
The Tribunal heard the State in his absence. It held that he had not discharged the burden that section 9 of the Foreigners Act places on a person in his position, and opined that he was a foreigner under section 2(a).
The petitioner: his lawyer never told him
Ms A. Begum, counsel for the petitioner, said he is a poor man who lives by share-cropping. His Tribunal lawyer, she said, had told him he need appear only on dates the lawyer would communicate.
She said the written statement had typographical errors and enclosed photocopies of voter lists and other papers that were not specified. The petitioner wanted to file a corrected written statement and lead evidence.
He learned of the opinion, she said, in early February 2023, when he heard while visiting relatives that the police were looking for him. He tried to find his former lawyer but could not, and says he came to know of the order on 2 March 2023.
Ms Begum added that after receiving the brief to file the petition she had misplaced the file while shifting her chamber, and found it again later. She asked the High Court to set aside the opinion and remand the matter.
The State: documents kept arriving after 2011
Ms A. Verma, Standing Counsel for Foreigners Tribunal and border matters, opposed the plea. She pointed to the dates on the papers the petitioner had annexed to his writ petition.
The NRC copy was printed on 4 April 2015. The 1971 voter list was obtained in 2014 and the certified jamabandi in 2018. Certified copies of the 1993 and 1985 voter lists came in 2020 and 2021, and the Gaon Bura certificate in 2014.
All of that came after the opinion, she said, so the petitioner could not have been unaware of the proceedings. His continued absence from 19 April 2010 showed to her that he was avoiding them.
Absent on date after date, costs left unpaid
The bench called for the Tribunal record. It showed the petitioner absent on 22 September 2006, 1 November 2006, 12 December 2006, 10 January 2007, 26 February 2007 and 18 April 2007, when the Tribunal ordered the case to proceed ex parte.
On 25 September 2008 a petition was filed to set aside that order. The Tribunal noted that no document had been placed before it to support the claim of illness.
On 20 December 2008 the Tribunal recalled the ex parte order, on condition that Rs 200 was deposited as costs. The costs were never paid, and the petitioner stayed away, sometimes with an application showing cause and mostly without one.
On 10 January 2011 the Tribunal imposed another Rs 250 and gave him a final opportunity to lead evidence. On 25 January 2011 it found that the costs had not been deposited and thought he was trying to delay the case, so it heard the State. He was absent on 17 March 2011, and the opinion followed on 21 March.
Two stories that did not match
The bench found a variation between the writ petition’s story and the Tribunal record. The petition blamed the petitioner’s lawyer for his absence. The record showed that the lawyer appeared on several dates without him and sought time to file the written statement, to recall the ex parte order and to lead evidence.
The bench said the Tribunal gave him “enough and more opportunities” and that he disregarded its orders when he did not pay the Rs 200 and Rs 250 costs (para 11).
It also rejected his claim that he knew nothing of the Tribunal’s orders before 2023. He had himself put on record several documents obtained between 2011 and 2023, while saying all such documents had been given to his Tribunal lawyer.
The proceedings had ended in 2011 and the certified copies were obtained afterwards. The bench said it could not believe that those documents had already been supplied to the lawyer, and held that the delay of 12 years had not been explained with an acceptable reason.
A petition held not bona fide
The bench went further. It said it was of the opinion that the petition was “not filed bona fide”, and agreed with the Tribunal that the petitioner had constantly tried to delay the proceedings (para 12).
In exercise of its Article 226 powers, the court said it saw no reason to differ from the Tribunal’s opinion of 21 March 2011. The order does not examine the documents the petitioner relied on for citizenship.
Order
The writ petition is dismissed. The court said “the consequences of the dismissal will follow” and did not spell them out.
The Registry is to return the records of the Foreigners Tribunal expeditiously, along with a copy of the order. The order, dated 16 November 2026, was passed by Justice Kalyan Rai Surana and Justice Rajesh Mazumdar.