Justice R. Kainthla Himachal Pradesh HC REVISION DISMISSED Cheque conviction upheld inrevision
[ Himachal Pradesh High Court ]

Himachal HC upholds Rs 81,300 apple cheque conviction as security plea had no defence evidence

Justice Rakesh Kainthla held that admitting the signature on a cheque is enough to raise the presumption under Section 139, and that an accused statement under Section 313 is not defence evidence. The six-month term and Rs 81,300 fine stand.

Atma Ram Tejta told a Rohru court that the cheque he gave an apple grower was only security. He never entered the witness box to say so. On 16 November the Himachal Pradesh High Court refused to disturb his conviction.

Justice Rakesh Kainthla dismissed Mr Tejta’s criminal revision against the concurrent findings of two courts. His six-month jail term and fine of Rs 81,300 under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act stand.

The judgment was reserved on 26 October 2026 and pronounced on 16 November.

73 boxes of apples and a bounced cheque

The complainant, Vinod Kumar Sood, is a horticulturist. He said Mr Tejta deals in the sale and purchase of apples and bought 73 boxes from him for Rs 81,300. Mr Tejta paid with a cheque for the same amount.

The bank returned the cheque with the endorsement “insufficient funds”. A legal notice came back unclaimed. Mr Sood then filed a complaint under Section 138 before the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate at Rohru.

Two courts, one verdict

Mr Sood examined himself as the sole complainant witness (CW1). In his statement under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Mr Tejta denied the case and said he had issued a security cheque for the apple cartons. He led no evidence despite repeated opportunities, and the trial court closed it.

The Magistrate convicted him on 1 March 2025. The sentence was six months of simple imprisonment, a fine of Rs 81,300 and one more month in default of the fine.

The Additional Sessions Judge, Rohru, upheld the conviction and sentence on 8 June 2026. Mr Tejta then came to the High Court in revision.

What the petitioner argued

Mr Atul G. Sood, appearing for Mr Tejta, said the security cheque defence was highly probable and both courts had wrongly rejected it. He argued that the complainant had produced no proof of the sale, so the presumption attached to the cheque should not have been applied.

In the revision, Mr Tejta also said he had repaid the money and that cross-examination of the complainant had discharged his burden. He called the sentence excessive. Nobody appeared for the complainant.

A revision is not a second appeal

The court began with the limits of its own jurisdiction. It relied on the Supreme Court’s 2026 ruling in Kuntegowda, which says a revisional court tests the correctness, legality and propriety of findings and does not act as an appellate court.

Under that ruling, interference is called for only where the order is perverse, grossly erroneous or glaringly unreasonable. It is also called for where the court below relied on irrelevant material, ignored relevant material or exercised discretion arbitrarily. The High Court said the revision had to be decided on those parameters.

A security cheque still raises the presumption

Mr Tejta did not dispute his signature. He had said in his Section 313 statement, and again before the High Court, that he gave a blank cheque as security. The court held that this admission was enough.

It cited Rajesh Jain, where the Supreme Court held that admitting the signature, without admitting the whole execution, triggers the presumptions under Sections 118(a) and 139. The burden then shifts to the accused to rebut them, and a bare denial does not do so.

Repayment claim surfaced only in revision

The court noted that Mr Tejta had not said in his Section 313 statement that he repaid the money. No proof of payment was produced before the trial court. The complainant denied in cross-examination that any cash had been paid.

On that point the judgment says:

“A denied suggestion does not amount to any proof” (para 18)

Mr Tejta also never stepped into the witness box. Relying on Sumeti Vij, the court held that a Section 313 statement is not substantive defence evidence and could not rebut the presumption.

No need to prove the apple sale

Mr Sood had admitted in cross-examination that he placed no document on record about his land and the apples. The defence said the courts should therefore have doubted his version.

The court disagreed. Citing the Supreme Court in Uttam Ram, Ashok Singh and Sanjabij Tari, it held that the Section 139 presumption removes the need to prove consideration. It also quoted the Supreme Court’s concern that some courts treat cheque cases as civil recovery proceedings.

Mr Sood’s statement was consistent, and nothing in cross-examination suggested he was lying. The two courts below had rightly accepted his testimony.

Dishonour memo and the unclaimed notice

The bank’s return memo corroborated the “insufficient funds” endorsement. Citing the Supreme Court in Mandvi Cooperative Bank, the court said such a memo is presumed correct until the accused disproves it.

The registered notice was returned with a note that Mr Tejta was not available at home. Relying on Vinod Shivappa and Alavi Haji, the court held that service is deemed to have been made unless the accused proves he was not responsible for non-service.

Mr Tejta did not do so. The court added that, as Alavi Haji says, a drawer who says he never got the notice can still pay within 15 days of the summons. The record showed he did not repay even after deemed receipt of the notice.

Sentence stays; fine called too low

On sentence, the court cited Bir Singh on the deterrent purpose of Section 138. It held that

“the sentence of six months cannot be said to be excessive” (para 36)

The fine equals the cheque amount. Citing Kalamani Tex, the court noted that courts should ordinarily levy a fine of up to twice the cheque amount with 9 percent simple interest.

It said Rs 81,300 was inadequate because the complainant lost the interest he would have earned and had to engage a lawyer. The complainant had filed no appeal, so the court could not touch the fine.

Order

The revision is dismissed, and all pending applications stand disposed of. The six-month sentence and the fine of Rs 81,300 imposed by the Rohru trial court remain in force.

The court directed that a copy of the judgment, along with the records of the courts below, be sent back forthwith.