Court-reserved post cannot cost him promotion: J and K HC orders notional benefit from 2011
Justice Rajnesh Oswal disposed of a 2010 service petition by directing the Centre to consider Guru Dutta Bhatt for notional promotion as Assistant Commandant (Electrical) from 30 December 2011, because his case was skipped only after the court kept one post vacant.
A petition filed in 2010 over a seniority list ended on 12 November 2026 over something narrower: a single post the High Court itself had kept vacant in 2011. Justice Rajnesh Oswal held that this cannot count against the petitioner, and directed the Union to consider his promotion on a notional basis from 30 December 2011.
The order was delivered orally by the Jammu bench of the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh in SWP No. 2720/2010. Guru Dutta Bhatt had asked for his seniority to be corrected. By the end, the dispute was only about when his promotion should take effect.
A seniority claim that was rejected as late
Mr Bhatt came to the High Court to quash an order of 7 January 2010. The respondents had rejected his representation for amendment or rectification of a seniority list, on the ground that it was time barred.
He also asked for a direction to place him ahead of two private respondents, S.C. Saxena and Hari Ram, in the central seniority list for the post of Inspector/JE (Electrical). The respondents filed a response objecting to the petition on various grounds.
While the case was pending, Mr Bhatt was promoted as Assistant Commandant (Electrical) with effect from 26 October 2012. The order does not record the respondents' grounds in detail.
What the petitioner still wanted
Ms S. Kour, Senior Advocate, appeared for the petitioner with Mr Michael Singh Dogra. She told the court that respondent No. 5 had died, and that Mr Bhatt now sought only consideration for promotion as Assistant Commandant (Electrical) with effect from 30 December 2011.
That was the date, she said, when other eligible candidates were considered and promoted for the vacancy year 2011-12. He was left out only because this court, by an order of 5 September 2011 in CMP No. 2559/2011, had kept one post of Assistant Commandant (Electrical) vacant.
She also drew the court to a communication of 8 May 2007 from the Deputy Inspector General (Staff) to the headquarters of the Special DG (WC), Border Security Force, Chandigarh, citing its paragraphs 7 and 8. Her submission was that his case went unconsidered at the promotion committee only because of the court's order.
The Centre: the court had tied its hands
Mr Vishal Sharma, Deputy Solicitor General of India, appeared with Mr Karan Sharma, Central Government Standing Counsel. The Centre's account ran parallel. Because of directions in two separate writ petitions, one by Mr Bhatt and one by N.C. Mishra, neither man was considered at the committee meeting of November 2011.
Mr Mishra's petition was disposed of on 20 March 2012, he said. Mr Mishra was then considered by the committee on 11 July 2012 and was not found suitable for promotion. The claim of Mr Bhatt, Mr Sharma added, was left out in November 2011 because of the court's directions.
A reserved post is not a reason
The court noted that the controversy had narrowed to the grant of promotion with effect from 30 December 2011. It said Mr Bhatt's case was not considered at the committee meeting of 9 November 2011 solely because this court had kept one post of Assistant Commandant (Electrical) vacant by its order of 5 September 2011.
Justice Oswal's reasoning was brief. Mere keeping of one post as reserved, he said, cannot prejudice the claim of the petitioner for promotional benefits, particularly as he was promoted on the vacancy reserved by this court for 2011-12.
The direction follows that logic. The respondents are to treat Mr Bhatt on the analogy of similarly situated candidates, who were promoted on 30 December 2011. The court confined the relief to notional benefits.
Order
The writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the respondents to consider the claim of Guru Dutta Bhatt for promotional benefits on a notional basis only, with effect from 30 December 2011, the day similarly situated candidates were promoted as Assistant Commandant (Electrical).
The court said it was sanguine that the respondents would pass the necessary order within three months of receiving a certified copy of the order. The connected applications, I.A. Nos. 212/2012, 3827/2010 and 2559/2011, are disposed of along with the petition.