A month to seize records, none seized: Kerala HC quashes takeover of Malabar milk union board
Justice Viju Abraham held that a Registrar who ordered an inquiry on 19 August could not claim on 18 September that a hearing would let the board tamper with records. He set aside the supersession and ordered the committee back on 24 November, limited to day-to-day work.
On 19 August the Registrar of Cooperative Societies ordered an inquiry into the Malabar Regional Co-operative Milk Producers’ Union. Four weeks later, on 18 September, she superseded its elected board without hearing it, saying a notice would give members time to doctor the records.
On 13 November the Kerala High Court set that order aside. Justice Viju Abraham found that in those four weeks the inspection team never seized a single document, and that the obstruction story appeared only later, in a counter affidavit.
The committee, elected to a term running to 4 February 2030, returns to office on 24 November. Until the fresh inquiry ends, it may run only day-to-day business and take no policy decisions.
Four weeks between inquiry and supersession
The five petitioners are the former chairman, K.S. Mani, and four board members of the Union. The committee took office on 5 February 2025. On 18 September 2026 the Director of Dairy Development, acting as Registrar, superseded it under Section 32 of the Kerala Cooperative Societies Act, 1969, by order Ext.P1.
The Registrar used Section 32(3), which lets her skip two safeguards when it is not reasonably practicable to follow them. One is a chance for the committee to state its objections under Section 32(1). The other is consultation with the financing bank and the State Co-operative Union under Section 32(2).
Ext.P1 gave one reason for skipping both. Time spent on those formalities, it said, would let the committee manipulate records, influence officials and destroy or rewrite files.
The timeline the petitioners laid out
The petitioners built their case on dates. On 19 August the Registrar ordered a statutory inquiry under Section 66(11) into the Union and its subsidiary, the Malabar Rural Development Foundation (MRDF). Two days later the Union’s Managing Director wrote that the committee would cooperate fully.
On 1 September Mr Mani wrote the same, and asked that the inquiry also cover the period before the committee took office. The inspection set for 16 September was confined to the subsidiary’s records, and on 11 September it was deferred without a date.
On 16 September the Registrar reconstituted the inspection team, adding the officer who became the Administrator under Ext.P1. That same day the team announced an inspection for 17 September. The MRDF chief executive asked for time to consult a lawyer.
The Joint Director, who headed the team, granted it, and told the MRDF the team would visit on 19 September. Ext.P1 was issued on 18 September, a day before that visit.
Six charges, and the board’s answers
The judgment sets out the charges in Ext.P1 with the petitioners’ answers. They covered annual reports and audited accounts of the subsidiary not placed before four general body meetings since 2022, and milk bought from the Sampathrao Deshmukh Co-operative Milk Union, with a loss of Rs 27,45,000 alleged. The petitioners say that milk had only a flavour defect.
They also covered a ghee stock shortfall at the Malappuram dairy store, spending on the inauguration of the Malappuram dairy, a Rs 25 lakh event alleged to secure a Rs 50 lakh grant, and wilful default by the Managing Director.
The petitioners denied each. They said the subsidiary’s accounts went to every general body meeting, and that the Rs 84,45,000 ghee shortfall was recovered in full before 31 March 2026. They said the committee had unanimously approved the inauguration spending for the Rs 131.03 crore Malappuram plant, and that the Rs 25 lakh event never took place.
On the subsidiary, they said the Registrar herself approved MRDF as a subsidiary on 22 February 2022, on an application of 13 May 2020. They added that the Union had given MRDF no financial help for ten years, so under Rule 13A(5) its auditors audit the subsidiary only to the extent of assistance given.
They added that the board includes a senior officer nominated by the Registrar, the Managing Director of the Kerala Co-operative Milk Marketing Federation and a person co-opted from the National Dairy Development Board. The Registrar’s nominee, they said, was present when the annual reports were approved and never objected.
They also relied on a judgment of 1 September 2026 in another petition by the MRDF, which they said limited the scope of inspection to what Rule 13A(5) prescribes. On the dairy fest, they said the Registrar’s own annual state event, Padavu, cost more than Rs 3 crore without audit.
On the Managing Director, they said he acts under Section 19A and Rule 53 on committee resolutions. Under bye-law 21.2.13, they said, severe action against him needs the prior concurrence of the National Dairy Development Board and the federation, KCMMF.
The court did not rule on any charge. It decided only whether the committee could be removed without a hearing.
What the State and the Union argued
For the Registrar, the Advocate General, Mr K. Jaju Babu, said the inspection team visited the MRDF on 17 September after notice. The management, acting on the committee’s directions, had wilfully and concertedly obstructed it, so a Section 32(1) notice would have been an empty formality, her counter affidavit said.
He also argued that the petitioners could appeal against Ext.P1. The Union and the Administrator, through Mr P.N. Mohanan, said illegalities had been found and pointed to an FIR. They said notice would have led to tampering. Mr M. Sasindran appeared for respondents 8 to 13, board members who joined the case.
Senior Advocate P. Deepak appeared for the petitioners. He argued that with an inquiry already running for a month, no urgency justified denying a hearing.
Gravity of charges does not excuse notice
Justice Abraham framed the single question:
“whether issuance of Ext.P1 order without affording an opportunity to the petitioners to state their objection as provided under Section 32(1) and the dispensation of consulting the financing Bank and the State Co-operative Union as required under Section 32(2) of the Act is in accordance with law” (para 7)
He said the court would test the answer against the reason Ext.P1 itself gave for skipping notice. The law, he noted, was settled by a Division Bench in Rajeevan T.V. v. K.A. Sukumaran (2013). Supersession of an elected board is an exception, and an elected body should normally finish its term.
That bench rejected the argument that the words not reasonably practicable allow a logical, not physical, test based on how serious the allegations are. It held that “an exception in an enactment has to be construed strictly” (para 7).
Notice can be dispensed with only if it is practically impossible to serve. Examples are members who refuse notice or cannot be found, or books that must be seized at once.
The court also cited its own ruling in Vellathooval Service Co-operative Bank v. Joint Registrar (2020), which followed the same reading. It added the Supreme Court’s holding in Sanjay Nagayach v. State of Karnataka (2013) that supersession of a democratically elected committee must rest on objective criteria.
An obstruction story that came late
Applying that test, the court held that the inspection team had ample opportunity to take the records. Ext.P2 was issued on 19 August. The team could have seized documents from that date but did not. It instead announced an inspection for 16 September, then deferred it, and then granted the MRDF extra time.
The State’s account of obstruction on 17 September did not fit that record. If the committee had blocked the team, the court reasoned, there would have been no occasion to grant additional time until 19 September under Ext.P15.
The Joint Director’s report of 17 September, Ext.R2(c), also says the MRDF only sought time to produce documents. It says nothing of any obstruction. Ext.P1 itself does not mention it either.
The court therefore treated the claim in the counter affidavit as an afterthought. It was raised, it held, to justify an order passed without hearing the committee or consulting the bank.
It held the supersession was:
“without any basis and against law and is liable to be interfered with” (para 11)
Months of opportunity already used
The court added a point about time. It had declined to stay Ext.P1 when the petition was filed. By its order of 23 September it had only let those petitioners who sit on the board of the Milma Federation continue there for ten days, and the arrangement was extended.
Since Ext.P1 operated unstayed, the authorities had from September until 10 November to inspect the premises and seize any relevant documents. The court treated that as further proof that no tampering risk justified skipping the notice.
Order
The writ petition is disposed of with six directions. Ext.P1 is set aside. The inspection team gets ten more days from 13 November to seize documents, if any, to prove its allegations.
On 24 November the respondents must replace the Administrator and reinstate the Managing Committee. The inspection team must finish within one month of receiving the judgment. The Registrar must then comply with Sections 32(1) and 32(2) and pass fresh orders within a further month.
Until those orders are passed, the reinstated committee may carry out only day-to-day activities and take no policy decision. If the inquiry and any Section 32 proceedings are not completed within the time allowed, the committee regains power to take policy decisions in accordance with law.