Madras HC keeps in-house engineers in post but orders direct recruitment after a 19-year wait
A Division Bench refused to strike down Tamil Nadu rules that opened Assistant Engineer posts to serving staff, but directed the Government and the TNPSC to fill the unfilled direct-recruit slots within a fixed timetable.
Two petitions filed in 2007 by an unemployed Agricultural Engineering graduate and a confederation of such graduates have ended with a direction that Tamil Nadu must fill Assistant Engineer posts by direct recruitment. On 17 November the Madras High Court declined to strike down the rules that opened those posts to in-service staff.
A Division Bench of Dr Justice G Jayachandran and Justice E Manoharan held that outsiders cannot ordinarily attack promotional avenues for serving employees. It still found a continuing deprivation of direct-recruit chances and ordered the Government and the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission to act within two months.
Two petitions, one grievance
G Nagrajan, a BE graduate in Agricultural Engineering from the 1993 batch, filed W.P.No.34990 of 2007. He is from a Scheduled Caste community. The Confederation of Agricultural Engineers, an association of unemployed graduates, filed W.P.No.37033 of 2007.
Both sought a declaration that Rules 2(a) and 3 of the Special Rules for the Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service are illegal and unconstitutional to the extent they allow recruitment by transfer to the post of Assistant Engineer. They also wanted every vacancy, including those held by transferees since 19 July 1994, notified for direct recruitment.
How the door was narrowed
The court traced the rules. The post of Assistant Engineer (Agricultural Engineering) was a Class V post that was originally filled by direct recruitment alone, through the Public Service Commission.
G.O.Ms.No.582 of 9 November 1995 added recruitment by transfer from Assistant Soil Conservation Officers, Junior Draughting Officers and Agricultural Engineering Foremen who held an engineering degree. The ratio between direct recruits and transferees was fixed at 24:1 from 27 December 1990 and raised to 91:9 from the date of the order.
The Government order said the earlier 2 per cent quota was inadequate. These staff, it said, should be rewarded with suitable fitment so the department could function harmoniously.
The Chief Engineer had suggested raising the share from 3 to 5 per cent. The Government chose fixed proportions instead, using a working strength of 465 Assistant Engineers on the date of the order.
A proviso added by G.O.Ms.No.431 in October 1996 went further. A Junior Engineer who acquired an engineering degree, or passed Sections A and B of the AMIE examination, would be re-designated Assistant Engineer from the day after the last examination, whatever the procedure for recruitment by transfer.
The court noted that the Public Service Commission had itself said a panel for such transfers was not practicable. The Government accepted its view and made the re-designation automatic. The same order added Rule 6-A to place re-designated officers below the directly recruited in seniority.
What the confederation said
The confederation argued that the amendments let the department fill every vacancy by transfer or re-designation. It said the 1995 amendment, made retrospective, set no minimum service and no test of suitability.
It pointed to G.O.Ms.No.479 of 16 November 2007, which re-designated 399 Assistant Soil Conservation Officers as Junior Engineers after 20 years of service. In its view the direct-recruit quota had become nil, and no graduates had been directly recruited for ten years.
The petitioners added that transfers ignored the 69 per cent reservation policy and Section 5 of the Tamil Nadu Reservation Act, 1993. They also said part-time degrees earned after repeated attempts compromised efficiency, contrary to Article 335. Their counsel was Mr N Subramaniyan.
The State’s answer
The Chief Engineer’s counter affidavit said direct recruitment could not run during the ban on recruitment, which the State placed between 2001 and 2005. After the ban lifted, the Public Service Commission notified 36 Assistant Engineer vacancies in 2006.
That process was stayed in W.P.No.4816 of 2008. Meanwhile, many Assistant Soil Conservation Officers had spent more than 20 years without promotion, and the Chief Engineer proposed re-designating them as Junior Engineers so they could move up.
Mr S Illamvaludhi, Special Government Pleader, argued that aspirants and serving staff are not equals. He said the petitioners were not in service and had no standing to challenge service rules, and that the amendments carried stated reasons with no malice in law or fact. Reservation, he added, applies at entry level only.
Judicial review of service rules
The Bench began by saying that rule-making power under Article 309 is not absolute. Rules governing public employment must satisfy Articles 14 and 16, and a person who can show a rule is arbitrary or discriminatory may invoke Article 226.
It found the quota for graduates under direct recruitment had been substantially reduced and, even then, had not been filled. The petitioners had therefore made out a prima facie case to be heard.
Two Supreme Court cases, read narrowly
The petitioners relied on K Narayanan v State of Karnataka (1994 Supp (1) SCC 44) and B Thirumal v Ananda Sivakumar (2014) 16 SCC 593. The State countered that both were seniority fights between direct recruits and promotees, not disputes between aspirants and serving staff.
The Bench agreed that the Karnataka observations on engineering services applied equally to Tamil Nadu. It noted a vital difference: the rule in K Narayanan was challenged promptly, by serving officers directly hurt by its retrospective effect.
In B Thirumal, the Bench recorded, the Supreme Court held that degree-holder Junior Engineers stay in the Subordinate Service after re-designation. The court there declined to unsettle past appointments, a position this Bench echoed.
Why the main prayer failed
On who may challenge service rules, the Bench said a challenge brought
“by persons not in service or outside the service is generally not sustainable” (para 33)
It said promotional avenues for serving staff cannot be questioned by aspirants, and re-designation for administrative reasons is outside judicial review. Granting the main relief would also unsettle appointments made over years.
The relief the court did give
The Bench still found that the grievance did not end with the rules. It took judicial notice of the many amendments and the failure to run periodic direct recruitment to fill the quota reserved for engineering graduates.
It directed the Government and the Commission to work out the number of substantive Assistant Engineer posts and how many are reserved for direct recruits. Where those slots are held by another feeder category, the same number of posts must be filled by direct recruitment.
People now holding slots meant for direct recruits stay on. The court directed that
“supernumerary posts are to be created” (para 34)
for them. They remain supernumerary until they join the mainstream under the catch-up principle, as slots meant for transferees fall vacant.
Order
The two writ petitions are disposed of with the directions in paragraph 34 of the order. The process of appointing Engineering graduates as Assistant Engineers through direct recruitment must start within two months of receipt of the order.
It must be completed within nine months after that. There is no order as to costs, and the connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
For the Government, the Special Government Pleader appeared. Standing counsel for the Public Service Commission were Mr B Vijay in W.P.No.34990 of 2007 and Mr I Abrar Md Abdulla in W.P.No.37033 of 2007.