Chief Justice S.A. Dharmadhikari Justice G.A. Murugan Madras HC REVISIONS DISMISSED Highest bid paid in full, butthe sale never closed
[ Madras High Court ]

Top bidder paid Rs 5.30 crore, still no sale: Madras HC says a stayed auction confers no right

A bench led by Chief Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari upheld the tribunal orders that let Punjab National Bank cancel a SARFAESI auction after confirmation had been stayed, and told the bank to get a fresh valuation before any new sale notice.

A Chennai property with a reserve price of Rs 5.29 crore drew a bid of Rs 5.30 crore at a bank auction on 27 December 2018. The bidder paid every rupee, and the bank wrote to acknowledge it. On 17 November the Madras High Court held that he had still bought nothing.

Chief Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari and Justice G Arul Murugan dismissed two revision petitions arising from the same property. One was filed by the auction purchaser and the other by the guarantor whose property was sold. Justice Arul Murugan wrote the order.

A bid Rs 1 lakh above reserve

Varadha Steels Private Limited borrowed from the Oriental Bank of Commerce, now merged with Punjab National Bank. The account turned into a non-performing asset on 30 September 2014. In 2016 the bank filed an original application before the Debts Recovery Tribunal for Rs 46,32,18,721.90.

The bank also moved under the SARFAESI Act. It issued a possession notice under Section 13(4) on 2 February 2017 and a sale notice on 12 November 2018. The property of the guarantor, AT Heera Banu, was fixed for auction on 27 December 2018.

The reserve price was Rs 5.29 crore.

A stay one day before the auction

The guarantor, her husband and the partnership firm challenged the sale notice before the tribunal. On 26 December 2018, the day before the auction, the tribunal passed a short interim order. It said the sale would proceed as per the sale notice, but confirmation was stayed.

The auction went ahead. CB Rajender bid Rs 5.30 crore and was declared the highest bidder.

The bank wrote to him the same day, telling him that the tribunal had stayed confirmation and asking him to complete the payment process.

He paid the full Rs 5.30 crore, and the bank acknowledged it by a letter of 9 January 2019. He did not apply to the tribunal to be made a party.

The bank withdraws its own notice

On 18 February 2019 the bank told the tribunal that it was withdrawing the sale notice because of defects in it, and asked that the guarantor’s application be closed as infructuous. The tribunal accepted the memo on 28 February 2019. It also asked the bank to consider the request to redeem the mortgage.

The guarantor then asked to redeem the property by paying Rs 5.30 crore. On 17 May 2019 the tribunal allowed that. It rejected the bank’s plea that the property was really worth Rs 7.83 crore and directed the bank to take the money and release the title documents.

The bank appealed to the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal in Chennai. The purchaser appealed against the withdrawal order. On 10 March 2021 the appellate tribunal reversed the redemption order, saying a property valued at more than Rs 7 crore could not be redeemed for Rs 5.30 crore.

By a separate order of the same day it partly allowed the purchaser’s appeal. It held that serious lapses in a sale notice mean no valid title passes.

The tribunal noted that the full Rs 5.30 crore had been refunded and awarded him Rs 5 lakh in compensation from the bank. Both sides then came to the High Court under Article 227.

What each side argued

Senior Counsel Om Prakash, for the purchaser, said that once the bank declared him the successful bidder and took the full price, his rights had crystallised. The bank could not withdraw unilaterally, and the guarantor had no right left to redeem.

He relied on three Supreme Court rulings: Janak Raj, IDBI Bank v. Ramswaroop Daliya and Golden Food Products India.

Senior Counsel Jayesh Dolia, for the guarantor, said the tribunal had rightly let her redeem at the highest bid. The appellate tribunal, he argued, had relied on a later valuation. She was still willing to redeem on a fresh and proper valuation.

Additional Solicitor General ARL Sundaresan, for the bank, said the dues stood at about Rs 46 crore and redemption needs payment of the whole debt. The bank could not confirm the sale while the stay was in force.

He also argued that the Authorised Officer’s letter was not the confirmation by the secured creditor that Rule 9(2) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 requires.

Bank and Authorised Officer are not two authorities

The court began by rejecting the bank’s reading of Rule 9(2). The Authorised Officer acts for the secured creditor and has no independent role. Once he declares a bidder successful, the bench said, nothing remains for anyone else to confirm:

“the Authorised Officer and the secured creditor cannot be construed as two different authorities” (para 14)

It rejected the purchaser’s argument just as firmly. The tribunal had barred confirmation before the auction took place, so the bank could proceed with the sale but could not conclude it. The bank had said exactly that to the bidder on the day.

The bidder could have gone to the tribunal

The bench said that, with that letter in hand, the purchaser could have applied to the tribunal to be impleaded and to have the sale confirmed. He chose instead to deposit the balance. Paying the money, it held, cannot amount to confirmation of a sale unless the court so declares.

The court then turned to the defects in the notice. The bank’s memo admitted discrepancies in the metes and bounds and the extent of the property. Because the bidder never joined the proceedings, the tribunal never ruled on the guarantor’s objections to publication, description or valuation.

The bench noted that the bank’s memo was not consistent about the defects. In one place it said the property had not been described with proper metes and bounds and the extent was wrong. In another it said the Kilpauk property was described properly and the discrepancies concerned the other properties.

Had the bank not filed the memo, the court observed, the tribunal would have decided the guarantor’s challenge on merits. Nothing stopped the purchaser, who knew of the interim order, from asking the tribunal to do exactly that.

On valuation, the bench said a later report cannot by itself undo a sale held on the valuation available beforehand. The report was dated 11 March 2019, about three months after the auction, and put the property at Rs 7.83 crore.

A gap of more than Rs 2.5 crore, it said, could not simply be brushed aside, especially with public money still owed to the bank.

Why the purchaser’s precedents did not apply

The court agreed that an auction sale carries sanctity and should not be disturbed without valid reasons. It listed the exceptions as collusion, fraud, or raising or underbidding, and said a mere irregularity does not suffice unless substantial injury follows. But in every decision the purchaser cited, the sale had been confirmed and no court had stayed confirmation.

Here the court found there was “no concluded sale” and no vested right in the purchaser (para 23). It relied on Mathew Varghese, which says that where a court intervenes in a sale, the purchaser’s rights crystallise only as per the court’s final order.

The bank had refunded the full amount on 15 March 2019, immediately after the tribunal’s order. The purchaser said he sent the money back by demand drafts, which the bank has not encashed.

Redemption stays open until a fresh notice

The court also looked at Section 13(8) of the Act, which bars a sale if the secured creditor’s dues are tendered before the auction notice is published. The sale notice here stands withdrawn and no fresh notice has issued. Until one does, the bench said, the guarantor can tender the dues and seek redemption.

It found no perversity or irregularity in the appellate tribunal’s orders. It added a direction aimed at the next round of the sale.

Order

Both civil revision petitions were dismissed, with no costs, and the connected interim applications stood dismissed. The bank must obtain a fresh valuation of the property and then issue a fresh sale notice.

The bank may consider an offer from the guarantor in line with that valuation, provided it is made before the fresh notice issues. Any demand drafts sent later by the auction purchaser and held by the bank must be returned at once.