Justice K.K. Babu Madras HC PETITION DISMISSED A bank's SARFAESI possession duringan award stay is held lawful
[ Madras High Court ]

Madras HC upholds award against Kumbakonam store: bank seizing shop during stay was no contempt

Justice K. Kumaresh Babu held that SARFAESI recovery and arbitration can run together, and that the stay on the award only barred recovery of the award amount. He gave the firm two months before any sale of the shop.

On 20 June 2026 Equitas Small Finance Bank took possession of a Kumbakonam utensils and furniture shop, five weeks after the Madras High Court had stayed an arbitral award against its owners. On 18 November the court held that the bank had not disobeyed that stay, and it dismissed both the challenge to the award and the contempt petition.

Justice K. Kumaresh Babu ruled that the stay protected the firm only from recovery of the award amount. It did not stop a secured creditor from taking possession under the SARFAESI Act.

Rs 10 crore of credit, then a downturn

The petitioners are Sri Kaleeswari Stores, a partnership firm retailing utensils, furniture and home appliances, and two of its partners. By a letter of 28 November 2017 the bank sanctioned Rs 10 crore: a Rs 3.5 crore cash credit and two term loans of Rs 1.53 crore and Rs 4.97 crore.

The firm hypothecated its stock and movables. The two partners signed guarantees on the same date, and one of them created an equitable mortgage by depositing title deeds in January 2018.

The petitioners said they repaid the Rs 1.53 crore term loan in full. They said a severe business downturn, worsened by Covid-19, then stopped them paying on time, and the accounts turned into non-performing assets.

Three tracks run by the bank

The bank first invoked the arbitration clause. It filed Section 9 applications, and on 20 September 2024 the court appointed an Advocate Commissioner to take an inventory of the hypothecated stock. The petitioners paid Rs 1 crore under a common order of 13 March 2025.

On 16 April 2025 the court appointed Justice K. Kannan, a retired judge, as sole arbitrator on the bank’s Section 11 petition. At the same time the bank used the SARFAESI Act, issuing notices under Sections 13(2) and 13(4).

The bank then applied under Section 14 to the Chief Judicial Magistrate at Kumbakonam, who allowed it on 22 April 2025. A writ in the Madurai Bench got an interim stay on 21 May 2025 on payment of Rs 10 lakh, but was dismissed on 25 August 2025 with a direction to use the alternative remedy.

The Debts Recovery Tribunal refused an injunction on 4 October 2025. A Division Bench then restrained the bank from taking physical possession, on payment of Rs 25 lakh, which the firm paid on 13 October 2025.

The award and the stay

The arbitrator made his award on 16 February 2026. As the petitioners described it, he held the firm and partners jointly and severally liable for Rs 7,52,32,079 with interest as stipulated, plus Rs 10 lakh in costs.

The firm sought a correction under Section 33, arguing that the deduction formula in clause 7.1(a) ignored Rs 1.35 crore already paid under court orders. The arbitrator dismissed that application on 8 March 2026.

On 14 May 2026 the High Court stayed the award, on condition that the firm deposit Rs 1 crore within eight weeks. Possession of the shop was taken on 20 June 2026. The firm’s application relies on a Rs 50 lakh demand draft of that date and asks for eight more weeks to pay the other Rs 50 lakh.

What the petitioners argued

Mr P.J. Rishikesh, for the petitioners, called the three parallel proceedings an abuse of process. He said that having chosen arbitration, the bank was barred by the doctrine of election from pursuing Section 14 of SARFAESI, and that the arbitrator was wrong to hold the doctrine inapplicable.

He argued the award double-charged his clients by nearly Rs 1 crore, and that clause 7.1(d), which protects SARFAESI recovery, went beyond the reference. He also said the arbitrator treated the Covid plea as a claim to wipe out the debt, when the firm had asked only for restructuring.

He added that the Rs 10 lakh costs had no breakdown. After the award, he said, the firm paid a further Rs 1.30 crore and the bank released part of the mortgage.

On contempt, he said the bank issued a possession notice on 10 June 2026 and entered the shop on 20 June, ignoring a notice that cited the stay.

What the bank answered

Mr Ravi, Senior Counsel for the bank, said the remedies run in distinct fields and may be pursued together, so there was no double jeopardy. He said hardship from Covid is not a ground for force majeure.

On computation, he said the petitioners left out the interest payable. On contempt, he said the 14 May order concerned the award alone, and the possession came from the Magistrate’s warrant of 22 September 2025 under SARFAESI.

Election, Covid and perversity

The judge began with the plea that the arbitral cause of action merged into SARFAESI. He relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in M.D. Frozen Foods Exports, (2017) 16 SCC 741, which held that

“the SARFAESI proceedings and the arbitration proceedings can go hand in hand” (para 30)

On the award itself, he found no perversity and no Wednesbury unreasonableness. The liability had been crystallised by the adjudicatory process of arbitration.

The Covid plea did not help, he said. The pandemic was long over by 2022, while the SARFAESI action began in August 2024 after the accounts turned non-performing.

Why the stay was not breached

The judge drew a line between adjudication and enforcement. Arbitration decides what is owed, while SARFAESI action protects the value of the asset, and he cited Transcore v. Union of India, (2008) 1 SCC 125, which likened possession to a receiver’s.

Interim protection against an award, he said, means only that the award cannot be enforced against the petitioners. The repossessed property remains subject to further SARFAESI steps, limited to the amount the award fixed.

The 14 May order, he held, barred only further proceedings to enforce the award by dealing with the repossessed security. He concluded that

“there has been no violation of the order dated 14.05.2026” (para 33)

Order

The arbitration petition and the contempt petition are dismissed, and the connected applications are closed. There is no order as to costs.

Because the award had been under interim protection, the court continued it for two more months so the firm can work out its remedies. Until then the bank must not sell the repossessed assets.

The judgment records the firm’s arguments on the computation clause and the costs, but gives no separate ruling on them beyond finding no ground to interfere under Section 34.