Orissa HC orders fresh valuation of ED-seized BMW and Harrier before owner can keep them
Justice G. Satapathy held that a PMLA Special Court ought to have used a recent valuation, not a March 2025 report, and directed it to fix a fresh fixed deposit for the owner within 15 days of receiving the new valuation.
A Special Court in Bhubaneswar priced a BMW and a Tata Harrier, both attached by the Enforcement Directorate, off a valuation certificate dated 17 March 2025. On 13 November the Orissa High Court held that the court ought to have worked from a recent report, and sent the valuation back to be done afresh.
Justice G. Satapathy disposed of a criminal revision by the owner, Akash Kumar Pathak, by modifying the order of 20 August 2026. The owner can still keep both cars, but only by depositing a fixed deposit receipt equal to their current value.
Sale allowed unless owner deposits Rs 55.5 lakh
The Directorate seized the two vehicles as part of the proceeds of crime in the case against Mr Pathak. The Deputy Director attached them provisionally on 29 December 2021 and 31 January 2023 under Section 5 of the Prevention of Money-laundering Act.
The Adjudicating Authority confirmed the attachments on 18 August 2022 and 30 June 2023, in O.A. Nos. 615 of 2021 and 806 of 2023. The court noted that Mr Pathak never challenged either confirmation before any forum.
The Directorate then asked the Special Judge, CBI-1, Bhubaneswar, for leave to sell the vehicles under Rule 4(2) of the Prevention of Money-Laundering (Taking Possession of Attached or Frozen Properties Confirmed by the Adjudicating Authority) Rules, 2013. Their condition was gradually deteriorating, it said, and maintenance costs were likely to exceed their value.
On 20 August 2026, in Criminal Misc. Case (PMLA) No. 12 of 2023, the Special Judge granted leave to sell. He also let Mr Pathak take the vehicles back on one condition.
By 15 September 2026 he had to furnish a fixed deposit receipt of Rs 55,50,000 from a nationalised bank at Bhubaneswar, in the name of the Director of Enforcement.
Property surety instead of cash
Dr Abhay Kant Pathak, Advocate, appeared for the petitioner. He argued that the valuation was a year and a half old, that the cars were standing in the open and losing value every day, and that the registered owner should be allowed to keep them as interim custodian.
His request was narrow. He asked to furnish property surety in place of the cash surety in the form of a fixed deposit.
Mr Rajat Kumar Panda, Advocate, appeared for the Directorate. He submitted that Rule 4(2) permits retention by the accused only on furnishing the value of the property as a fixed deposit, so the Special Judge had acted rightly.
Who can attach, and who can release
Justice Satapathy first set out the statutory scheme. Section 5 lets the Deputy Director attach property considered to be proceeds of crime for up to 180 days. The officer must file a complaint with the Adjudicating Authority within 30 days of the attachment.
Under Section 8(3), the Adjudicating Authority can confirm the attachment or the retention of property. Section 8(7) covers a trial that cannot be concluded, for example on the accused’s death or declaration as a proclaimed offender.
In that situation the Special Court, on an application by the Director or by a person claiming possession, passes orders for confiscation or release. Read together, the court said, there was no dispute about the Authority’s power to attach or the court’s power to confiscate or release.
What the second proviso to Rule 4(2) says
On the plea for property surety, the court turned to the second proviso to Rule 4(2). It applies where the movable property is a conveyance. The authorised officer may obtain a valuation report from the Motor Licensing Authority or another authority.
The officer may then accept and retain a fixed deposit receipt of a nationalised bank equal to the value, as security in the Director’s name. A report goes to the Special Court or the Adjudicating Authority.
The court read that proviso with Section 8(7) and held that the Special Court can direct release of a seized vehicle to the person entitled to possession.
The proviso speaks only of a fixed deposit receipt. The order does not extend retention to property surety.
A valuation from March 2025
The court found the flaw in the figure. The Special Judge had relied on the valuation report of 17 March 2025, more than a year and a half old. Justice Satapathy said he ought to have taken a recent report.
Mr Pathak can retain the vehicles by producing a fixed deposit receipt equal to their value. If he does not do so within a reasonable time, the authorised officer may sell them with leave of the Special Court or the Adjudicating Authority.
The sale proceeds go into a government treasury, a State Bank of India branch or a nationalised bank in a fixed deposit, and the officer retains the receipt.
Order
The criminal revision is disposed of by modifying the order of 20 August 2026. Mr Pathak may retain the vehicles by furnishing a fixed deposit receipt equal to their value as determined by the Authority.
The Special Judge shall obtain a fresh valuation report and pass an order giving Mr Pathak a chance to produce a fixed deposit receipt of a nationalised bank equal to the recent value, in the name of the Director of Enforcement. If he fails, the vehicles are to be dealt with in accordance with law and the Rules.
The Special Judge must pass that order within 15 days of receiving the valuation report, after giving both Mr Pathak and the Directorate an opportunity.