Orissa HC sets aside Rs 25 lakh alimony resting on one line that a wife earned over Rs 90,000
A Division Bench upheld the unchallenged divorce but held the Family Court fixed permanent alimony with no income, asset or status material on record. It sent the issue back for a fresh decision within about two months of the parties appearing.
The Bhubaneswar Family Court fixed a wife’s permanent alimony at Rs 25 lakh after noting two things: her husband’s job titles and her testimony that she earned more than Rs 90,000 a month. On 16 November the Orissa High Court called that a guess and set the figure aside.
A Division Bench of Dr Justice Sanjeeb K Panigrahi and Justice Murahari Sri Raman left the divorce decree untouched, because neither side had challenged it. It sent only the amount of alimony back to the Family Court for fresh adjudication.
A marriage of 2012, a suit of 2016
Dr Atish Kumar Pattanaik married Sumita Pruseth on 26 February 2012 at Bargarh. He says he was then working as a Deputy Manager at OCL India Ltd., Rajgangpur, and she as a software tester at CSM Technology in Bhubaneswar.
His case is that she left his family home at Sundargarh on 2 February 2013 and never returned despite his efforts. In 2016 he sued for divorce under Section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, registered as Civil Proceeding No. 162 of 2016.
What the Family Court decided
The Family Court judge, in a judgment of 30 April 2024, found that both sides had made a series of allegations of torture against each other. It held they could not live in peace and granted the husband a divorce.
On permanent alimony, the court noted that he was an Assistant Manager when they married and a Deputy Manager in 2017. It recorded her evidence as a Senior Test Lead earning more than Rs 90,000 a month. It then fixed Rs 25 lakh, citing the economic status, needs, potentialities, social status and age of the parties and the price index.
The husband’s case against the figure
Senior Advocate Susanta Kumar Dash, with Advocate Subrat Kumar Das, appeared for Dr Pattanaik. He argued that the Family Court never brought on record definite material about the husband’s income and expenses or assessed the status of both sides.
He called the amount a “wild guess” and said the wife had left home of her own will. Advocate Ananta Narayan Pattanayak, for Ms Pruseth, said the appeal was meant to delay payment and that she left because of cruelty.
Divorce settled, only money left
The bench recorded that both counsel conceded they had not questioned the divorce. It said the allegations on both sides showed no intention to continue the marriage and an irretrievable breakdown. It then framed the dispute:
“The lis in the present appeal hovers round the determination of quantum of permanent alimony as awarded by learned Family Court.” (para 7)
Words that showed there was no material
The bench said the Family Court had analysed no material, and nothing had been shown to it that income, asset or status particulars were laid before that court. Even a rough estimate, it said, must refer to the record.
It treated the hedged wording of the Family Court’s reasoning as a sign that there was either no material or that available material was ignored. The husband’s income could have been assessed by calling for particulars of his post.
A bare statement that the wife earned more than Rs 90,000 a month was not enough. On the Family Court’s conclusion, the bench held that it
“is based on no evidence” (para 7.3)
The Supreme Court framework the court applied
The bench relied on the Supreme Court in Jiya and Aditi alias Mithi, which apply the guidelines in Rajnesh. Those factors include the status of the parties, the needs of the wife and children, qualifications and employment, independent income or assets, and the husband’s financial capacity.
The judgment also reproduces the directions on a mandatory Affidavit of Disclosure of Assets and Liabilities in maintenance proceedings. The respondent must file the affidavit with the reply within four weeks, and courts may not grant more than two opportunities for it.
It noted the Supreme Court’s remark in Aditi that parties often file scanty material, with wives tending to exaggerate needs and husbands to conceal income. That is why the guidelines were framed.
A warning the High Court had already issued
The bench pointed to its own earlier decision in Sahoo Smruti Prava Sahoo, reported as 2025 ILR-CUT-ONLINE 262. There the High Court had flagged that trial courts were not following the Supreme Court guidelines.
That decision recorded that Rajnesh was delivered on 4 November 2020 and circulated to all courts. It remitted the matter because a court bound to follow guidelines had not done so.
The bench held that in deciding the alimony issue, the Family Court had not followed the method laid down in Aditi alias Mithi and Jiya.
Order
The divorce decree of 30 April 2024 stands as unchallenged. The High Court set aside the judgment only to the extent it fixed permanent alimony at Rs 25 lakh.
The Family Court, Bhubaneswar, must decide the alimony issue afresh, applying the guidelines and relevant factors. Both parties must appear before it on or before 26 November 2026 with a copy of the order, so no notices are needed.
The exercise is to be completed preferably within two months of both parties appearing, and both must cooperate and produce relevant material. The appeal is allowed to that extent, pending applications are disposed of and there is no order as to costs.