Justice H. Tandon Orissa HC ARBITRATOR APPOINTED Two arbitrators died, but theclause lives on
[ Orissa High Court ]

Two arbitrators died, the clause did not: Orissa HC revives a 2009 iron ore arbitration

Chief Justice Harish Tandon held that the death of two arbitrators ends the tribunal but not the arbitration clause, rejected a Section 29A time-bar objection, and appointed a former Supreme Court judge as presiding arbitrator.

An iron ore dispute that went to arbitration in 2009 has lost two of its three arbitrators to death. On 12 November 2026 the Orissa High Court held that their deaths ended the tribunal but not the arbitration clause, and appointed a former Supreme Court judge to preside.

Chief Justice Harish Tandon, deciding a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, also rejected the argument that the time limit in Section 29A had run out. The new tribunal is to continue from where the old one stopped.

Two mining agreements from 2002

Two agreements dated 15 May 2002 were made between the predecessors of Core Minerals and of Himanghini Singh. One was for raising iron ore and the other for selling it. The opposite party's predecessor held a mining lease from the Government and traded as a sole proprietor.

Both agreements carried the same arbitration clause. Disputes were to go to two arbitrators, one named by each side, with a speaking award. The place of arbitration was Bhubaneswar.

Core Minerals said the other side demanded more than the agreed amount, which obstructed both the raising and the sale of ore. It invoked the clause by a letter of 16 August 2009.

From the district court to the Supreme Court

Core Minerals first sought interim relief under Section 9 before the District Judge, Bhubaneswar, in Arbitration Petition No. 180 of 2009. It got none. An appeal to the High Court, ARBA No. 93 of 2009, brought no change either.

It then went to the Supreme Court by special leave petition No. 24007 of 2010. While that was pending, each side named its arbitrator. On 22 November 2011 the Supreme Court disposed of the petition, appointed a third arbitrator as chairman and left Core Minerals free to seek interim relief from the tribunal under Section 17.

Core Minerals filed its statement of claim. According to the petition, no counter claim came despite notice, and when one was finally filed after several adjournments, the tribunal accepted it without dealing with the objection.

That order was challenged in W.P.(C) No. 20900 of 2012, and the High Court stayed the tribunal’s proceedings. While the writ petition was pending, the presiding arbitrator and Core Minerals’ own arbitrator died. The mining lease expired by efflux of time, and the father of the opposite party also died without the other side being told.

Letters that went unanswered

Core Minerals withdrew the writ petition. The High Court allowed that on 30 October 2023, with liberty to raise all points before a newly appointed tribunal.

The company wrote on 5 October, 28 November and 20 December 2023. It named a new arbitrator on its side and asked the opposite party to confirm its own nominee and to join in choosing a presiding arbitrator. There was no reply, so it came to the High Court.

Mr Partha Mukherji, Advocate, appeared for Core Minerals. He argued that once two arbitrators died, the mandate of the tribunal ended under Section 15, and Section 29A could not arise. Death does not invalidate the agreement, he said, and nothing stops the court from constituting a tribunal.

He relied on Huawei Technologies Company Ltd v. Sterlite Technologies Ltd, Khorshed E. Nagarwalla v. Daryus Soley Panthakey and Shailesh Dhairyawan v. Mohan Balkrishna Lulla. Since the opposite party’s nominee was alive, he said, the court need only appoint the presiding arbitrator.

The time-limit objection

Mr Lalitendu Mohapatra, Advocate, appeared for Himanghini Singh. The counter affidavit took one main point. Once the period for making an award under Section 29A expired without an extension, it said, the petition was time barred.

Section 29A fixes the time within which an arbitral tribunal must make its award. The opposite party’s case was that the clock had stopped and nobody had extended it.

What Section 15(2) requires

The Chief Justice began with Section 15, which he called an exhaustive provision on the termination of an arbitrator’s mandate. Under sub-section (2), a substitute is to be appointed according to the rules applicable to the appointment of the arbitrator being replaced.

He turned to Yashwith Construction (P) Ltd v. Simplex Concrete Piles India Ltd, which the court quoted at length. There the Supreme Court held that the procedure the parties agreed in their arbitration clause partakes of the character of a rule for this purpose.

In Huawei Technologies the Supreme Court treated an application under Section 11(6) as premature because the petitioner had not first given notice and tried to name an arbitrator by consent. The notice step came first, and only then the court.

The court also quoted Shailesh Dhairyawan at length. That judgment held that if a fresh appointment is not made despite written notice, nothing stops the court from stepping in, provided the appointment procedure was strictly followed.

Mandate ends, agreement stays

Applying those decisions, the Chief Justice held that even on the death of an arbitrator the mandate terminates, and Section 15(2) leaves no bar on the court appointing a presiding arbitrator. Both Core Minerals’ nominee and the Supreme Court’s appointee had died during the writ petition, and the company had written at once.

Core Minerals had also sought the opposite party’s concurrence for its own nominee, which in the Chief Justice’s view was not even warranted. On the clause itself he said:

“it does not terminate the arbitration clause” (para 10)

The clause therefore remains binding on both sides, the Chief Justice said, and the parties “cannot wriggle out of” it.

Why Section 29A did not apply

On Section 29A the court said the objection was misplaced. Once an arbitrator’s mandate terminates and the tribunal becomes defunct, the question of applying that section does not arise.

The words “mandate of the arbitrator terminates” mean, in the court’s reading, that the composition of the tribunal is affected. That leaves nothing to prevent the court from appointing a substitute.

The opposite party had also named an arbitrator who was still alive, and no letter withdrawing that appointment had been sent. The court presumed that nomination continues. Core Minerals’ nominee had been properly communicated under the clause.

Order

Under Section 11(6), the High Court appointed Mr Justice Ananga Kumar Patnaik, a former Judge of the Supreme Court of India, as presiding arbitrator. He sits with the arbitrators nominated by each side.

The tribunal is to start from the stage at which the earlier tribunal became defunct. The arbitration will be held under the aegis of the High Court of Orissa Arbitration Centre.

The arbitrators’ remuneration is to be paid equally by the parties, as may be agreed. The tribunal must try to keep to the Section 29A time limit. A copy of the judgment was ordered to go to the presiding arbitrator forthwith, and the petition was disposed of.