Justice S.K. Panigrahi Justice M.S. Raman Orissa HC ORDER REVERSED Hirakud Dam clerk family losesdecades-old arrears award
[ Orissa High Court ]

Orissa HC reverses Hirakud Dam arrears award: the clerk was on the regular rolls in 1960

A Labour Court had ordered arrears for a man who began as a work-charged time keeper in 1950. The High Court held his service book put him in a regular clerk post from 1954, outside the Supreme Court relief of 1985.

In March 1950 a man joined the Hirakud Dam Project as a time keeper on Rs 50 a month plus allowance. By September 1954 he was a regular clerk, and he retired in 1980. On 18 November the Orissa High Court held that his widow, who applied in 2012, could not use a Supreme Court ruling meant for work-charged workmen.

A division bench of Justice Sanjeeb K Panigrahi and Justice Murahari Sri Raman set aside a Labour Court order of 21 December 2013. That order had told the Water Resources Department to compute the husband’s central-scale benefits and pay them within three months. Justice Murahari Sri Raman wrote the judgment, and Justice Panigrahi agreed.

A dam, a takeover and 1,200 workmen

Hirakud Dam was first built under the Central Waterways, Irrigation and Navigation Commission. Its work-charged staff drew the pay of the Central Public Works Department. The State took over the project on 1 April 1960, on the understanding that staff recruited before that date would keep their scales.

Staff hired later were paid Odisha work-charged scales. To remove the gap, the State terminated the pre-1960 workers in 1963 and offered them posts on State scales. The workmen raised Industrial Dispute Case 3 of 1964, and the Tribunal held the terminations were not retrenchment.

The Supreme Court disagreed in Civil Appeals 348 and 349 of 1974, decided on 13 August 1985. It declared that workmen in the Hirakud work-charged establishment from before 1 April 1960 were entitled to the same pay and conditions as before, as if they were Central Public Works Department work-charged staff.

On 9 February 1988 the Supreme Court told the Labour Court at Sambalpur to implement that order, with 10 per cent yearly interest on arrears due for more than a year. The Labour Court then laid down three tests in Order 8 of 25 May 1989, and only workers who met them could claim.

The worker had to be in service on 31 March and 1 April 1960. He had to hold a termination notice of the 1963 kind. And he had to have been moved to a State post without a break in service.

A widow’s claim, 27 years on

Kumudini Satpathy applied to the Labour Court on 1 September 2012 under Section 33C(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. She said her husband, Sachidananda Satpathy, joined as a time keeper on 9 March 1950 in the work-charged establishment, and was made a Lower Division Clerk in September 1954.

He retired on superannuation in 1980 and died on 20 June 1983, two years before the Supreme Court order. She said he could not apply earlier because of ignorance, and asked the Labour Court to condone the delay and identify him as eligible.

The department objected on 16 November 2013. It said he was appointed a Lower Division Clerk in the regular establishment by an order of 20 September 1954, in the scale of Rs 55-130, and joined on 23 September 1954. He became an Upper Division Clerk on 1 April 1960 and a Circle Upper Division Clerk on 11 September 1961.

The Labour Court first looked at the papers the widow filed. A memo of 27 March 1950 showed the husband was engaged on a work-charged basis at Rs 50 plus dearness allowance, and the department did not dispute it.

The department then produced his duplicate service book. Its first volume showed him a Lower Division Clerk from 20 September 1954 in the Left Bank Building Division, moved to Canal Division No. II on 1 January 1959, and given six months’ notice that his services were not needed after 31 March 1960.

The Labour Court allowed the claim on contest. It held the 1950 appointment undisputed, and noted the service book notice that his services were not needed after 31 March 1960. It treated his appointment by the State the next day, as Upper Division Clerk in the Main Dam Division, as covered by the Supreme Court order.

The department filed W.P.(C) 13548 of 2015. On 21 March 2017 the High Court stayed the Labour Court order in the interim. Kumudini Satpathy died on 21 December 2019, and her two sons and two daughters were substituted on 25 February 2025.

The heirs filed a memo on 10 November 2026 saying that, despite scores of memos, the petition had not been listed. The bench heard it finally on 11 November and reserved judgment.

What the State argued

Mr Satyabrata Mohanty, Additional Government Advocate, appeared for the State with Ms Sarita Moharana, Additional Standing Counsel. He said the 1964 dispute covered 1,200 work-charged workmen out of about 2,300, and that the husband had left that establishment by promotion in 1954.

He argued that the husband then enjoyed regular State scales and promotions until retirement, and never raised a claim in his lifetime. His widow, he said, had set up a stale claim for benefits meant strictly for work-charged staff on 31 March and 1 April 1960.

He also argued that Section 33C(2) is a remedy to recover dues that already exist and are not disputed. The Labour Court, he said, had gone beyond that by deciding a fresh entitlement while the husband’s employment status was contested.

The duplicate service book in three volumes, filed with the objection, showed the true position, he said. A finding that ignored it was perverse.

What the heirs argued

Mr Basudev Pujari appeared for the legal heirs. He said the facts were undisputed and that the Labour Court had found, in line with the Supreme Court order, that the husband joined as a time keeper in the work-charged establishment before 1 April 1960.

He submitted that the department should compute the entitlement and pay it to the heirs. The widow had not enjoyed the relief, he said, because the High Court stayed it in 2017 and she died while the writ petition was pending.

The service book decides it

The bench began with the plea of ignorance. The husband died in 1983, before the Supreme Court order of 1985, yet the application is dated 2012. The bench held the plea false, since his service book showed promotion into the regular establishment long before 1 April 1960.

On the tests of 1989, the bench noted that the heirs produced no document showing the husband was retrenched by a notice referring to the Government letter of 9 February 1963. They relied on his work-charged start in 1950, which the department did not dispute.

The bench then turned to the question that mattered, which was where he stood on the date of the takeover. It relied on a High Court order of 18 May 2017, which recorded that the original service book, produced by the State, showed regular appointment as Lower Division Clerk from 1954.

Counsel for the heirs sought time that day to take instructions. The bench found that, despite that opportunity, nothing had come forward to contradict the fact that the husband was in the regular establishment on 31 March and 1 April 1960 and was later promoted.

The bench read the Supreme Court order of 1985 by its terms. The protection, it held, was for work-charged workers engaged before 1 April 1960 and allowed to continue under the Odisha Government order of 8 September 1961.

“confined to the employees who were working in the work-charged establishments” (para 7.6)

It added that the Supreme Court decision had to be read as a whole, not by picking a sentence. For that he cited Paltronics Allied Industries Pvt Ltd v State of Odisha, a division bench ruling of 12 November 2026 in W.A. 1448 of 2026.

Delay was not the ground

The judgment also reproduced a coordinate bench ruling on fence-sitters, Dr Karunakar Sahoo v State of Odisha (W.P.(C) 20648 of 2016, decided 27 June 2017). It says delay and acquiescence can defeat a claim made only after others won, but not where the earlier judgment was meant to benefit everyone similarly placed.

The bench moved on without resting on that principle. It decided the claim on the husband’s status on 1 April 1960.

The department’s argument on the limits of Section 33C(2) was recorded but not separately decided. The judgment treats the Labour Court finding as wrong on the evidence.

Why the Labour Court was held wrong

The bench held that the Supreme Court order of 13 August 1985, read with the order of 9 February 1988, had no application to these facts. The husband was a Lower Division Clerk in regular service when the State took over the project.

The Labour Court had reasoned that, because he started as a time keeper in 1950, he qualified. The High Court held that this reasoning was perverse and misread the evidence.

“perverse, based on erroneous appreciation of evidence on record” (para 8.2)

It concluded that the legal heirs were not entitled to the relief sought in the application of 1 September 2012.

Order

The Labour Court order of 21 December 2013 in Industrial Dispute Misc. Case 1 of 1988 (SC), numbered 782, is set aside. The writ petition of the Department of Water Resources and the Superintending Engineer, Hirakud Dam Circle, succeeds.

The writ petition is disposed of, any pending interlocutory applications are disposed of, and there is no order as to costs. The judgment was pronounced on 18 November 2026 after a hearing on 11 November.