Justice S. Mishra Orissa HC REVIEW ALLOWED Reservation rule split at 19August 2023
[ Orissa High Court ]

Orissa HC reworks 2025 ruling: reservation law covers Gram Rozgar Sevak ads from 19 August 2023

Justice Sashikanta Mishra allowed review petitions by the State after finding that a 2023 amendment to the reservation Act was never placed before the court, and split the 2025 ruling at 19 August 2023.

The Orissa High Court had interfered with a guideline applying reservation to the engagement of Gram Rozgar Sevaks. Then the State told it that a 2023 amendment to the reservation Act had never been put before the judges. On 13 November the court agreed, and rewrote part of its February 2025 ruling around a date: 19 August 2023.

Justice Sashikanta Mishra allowed four review petitions filed by the State of Odisha. Engagements made before 19 August 2023 stay outside the reservation law. Advertisements issued on or after that date are governed by the Act as amended.

What the 2025 judgment decided

The judgment of 6 February 2025 in WP(C) No. 21256 of 2021 and batch dealt with Comprehensive Guidelines dated 6 April 2018. They applied the Odisha Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Act, 1975, to the engagement of Gram Rozgar Sevaks, or GRSs.

The court interfered with the guidelines to that extent, and with the consequential advertisements of 30 June 2018 and 24 March 2021. It issued a general direction. The State has now come back on review under Order XLVII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The amendment nobody mentioned

The State’s case was short. The Odisha Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Amendment Act, 2023, came into force on 19 August 2023. It inserted sub-section (2) in Section 3 of the 1975 Act.

The new sub-section extends reservation to tenure, contractual and schematic posts that are to be regularised against sanctioned posts. The State said this was not brought to the court’s notice when the writ petitions were heard, and that it bears on how GRSs are engaged.

5,484 vacancies and 23 districts

Mr S.N. Patnaik, Additional Government Advocate, argued for the State. He said that after GRSs were absorbed into the cadre of Accountant-cum-Data Entry Operators, 5,484 of the 6,794 sanctioned GRS posts were lying vacant.

Mr Patnaik submitted that the amendment had materially altered the statutory position. It was inadvertently not brought to the court’s notice during the hearing of the writ petitions, he said.

Three districts issued advertisements to fill GRS posts before 19 August 2023. Twenty-three districts did so after that date. Those later recruitments, he said, must be looked at in the light of the amended Act, and the judgment should be modified so it does not hold them up.

Mr J. Gupta, who appeared for persons affected by the judgment, made the same point about the 23 districts. The original writ petitioners were served but did not appear.

The court’s reasons for reviewing

The court found that the notification of 7 November 2023, which had a bearing on the issue, was not brought to its notice during the writ petitions. The earlier judgment, it said, dealt mainly with the validity of the 2018 guidelines and the two advertisements.

The effect of the amendment, which came into force on 19 August 2023, was not considered because no party raised it. The court said the later advertisements “stand on a different statutory footing” in view of the new sub-section.

As the judgment under review did not separate advertisements issued before and after that date, it had produced a general direction affecting all of them. The court held that a modification was needed to avoid confusion about advertisements issued after 19 August 2023.

What the new paragraphs say

The court allowed the review petitions to the extent of modifying the 2025 judgment. It inserted a new paragraph 29-A, which reproduces the amended provision, and substituted paragraph 30.

The inserted text records that sub-section (2) applies reservation to all tenure, contractual or schematic posts which are to be regularised against sanctioned posts. Under the Amendment Act the sub-section is deemed to have come into force on 19 August 2023.

The substituted paragraph 30 holds that until 19 August 2023 the Act had no enabling provision to extend reservation to such posts. The benefit, it follows, could not extend to engagements before the amendment, since the amendment is prospective in operation.

The 2018 guidelines therefore cannot be sustained so far as they make the Act strictly applicable to engagements made before 19 August 2023. The advertisement of 30 June 2018 providing reservation for all 19 vacancies also cannot be sustained.

The court then clarified the other side of the split. By prevailing law it means law in conformity with the amended provisions of the Act:

“advertisements issued on or after 19.08.2023 shall be governed by the prevailing law” (substituted para 30)

Order

The review applications are allowed to the extent of modifying the judgment of 6 February 2025 in WP(C) No. 21256 of 2021 and batch. The new paragraph 29-A is inserted and paragraph 30 is substituted as set out above.

The four review petitions, RVWPET Nos. 165, 166, 167 and 169 of 2026, were decided together. The opposite parties are Laxman Sarbhang and others in two of them, Biswaranjan Panigrahi in one, and Suratha Suna and others in the fourth.