Charged with murder on a name heard in the village: Punjab and Haryana HC discharges accused
Justice Manisha Batra held that a complainant who learnt the accused name from an unnamed source gave hearsay, not evidence, and that the approver account left no room for a fourth man. Charges under Sections 302 and 120-B IPC were quashed.
The complainant never claimed to have recognised him. More than three months after his brother was killed, he told the police only that he had learnt, at his own level and from his village, that one of the men was Alok Shah. On 13 November, the Punjab and Haryana High Court held that this was not evidence.
Justice Manisha Batra set aside the sessions court’s order of 12 July 2016, so far as it concerned Mr Shah. The charges under Sections 302 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code were quashed and he was discharged. His trial had been stayed since 3 October 2016.
A killing in a locked quarter in Phagwara
FIR No. 69 of 17 June 2012 was registered at Police Station Sadar Phagwara, Kapurthala, on the statement of Nathuni, who ran a flower stall on Banga Road. His brother Raghu had returned from Bihar on 16 June.
That night at about 9 or 10, a man named Rajiv came to meet Raghu with two others, aged about 40 and 25.
They stayed the night at the complainant’s house. Next morning Raghu went to the fields on a motorcycle, and Rajiv and his companions followed on foot. At about 10, a rickshaw puller told the complainant that Raghu and three others were drinking and cooking meat in the quarter.
At 12.30 pm the rickshaw puller returned to say Raghu was lying inside, and the quarter was locked from outside. The complainant and another brother broke the lock. They found Raghu dead in a pool of blood, with a deep injury on his head.
The FIR suspected Rajiv and his companions, who had also taken Raghu’s motorcycle and mobile phone. It gave a motive: the murder of one Vijay Kumar at a marriage party in Sitamarhi, Bihar, on 13 June 2012, in which the name of another brother had been taken.
How the third man was found
On 23 June 2012 police raided a house in Delhi and found the driving licence of Yogesh Kumar. The complainant identified the photograph as that of one of Rajiv’s companions, and Yogesh was nominated. The petitioner was not named in the FIR.
On 29 September 2012 the complainant gave a supplementary statement naming Mr Shah. Police arrested him on 12 January 2014. Yogesh surrendered in February 2014, and Rajiv was arrested on 11 March 2014.
In their disclosure statements, Yogesh and Rajiv each named one Bharat as the third man. Bharat, also called Bharat alias Pandit, was never arrested and has been declared a proclaimed offender. The case was committed to the Sessions Court on 13 October 2014.
Yogesh then applied for pardon under Section 307 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. It was granted on 5 January 2016, and on 15 January 2016 he gave a statement under Section 164. He named himself, Rajiv and Bharat Jha, said Rajiv hit Raghu on the head with a tawa, and did not name Mr Shah.
Despite that, the Additional Sessions Judge, Kapurthala, framed charges under Sections 302 and 120-B on 12 July 2016. The order said the supplementary statement specifically alleged Mr Shah’s involvement. At the charge stage, it added, the court need only be satisfied of sufficient ground to proceed.
The High Court stayed the trial against Mr Shah on 3 October 2016, and clarified on 8 October 2018 that the stay did not cover the co-accused. Rajiv Dass was convicted of murder on 16 November 2018 and sentenced to life imprisonment. He was acquitted of the conspiracy charge.
Two sides, one supplementary statement
Mr Sunil Chadha, Senior Advocate, appeared for Mr Shah. He argued that there was no eyewitness and no test identification parade. The name came more than three months later through a statement that was pure hearsay, and the approver had not named him.
He said police themselves had found Mr Shah innocent in case diary entries and sought his discharge, which a magistrate declined on 4 February 2014. He also said Mr Shah was not in Punjab that day. A family related to the complainant, he added, had a land dispute with Mr Shah’s grandfather.
Ms Ruchika Sabherwal, Senior Deputy Advocate General, Punjab, appeared for the State. She said the complainant named Mr Shah in the supplementary statement and again as a witness, and that at the charge stage only a prima facie case is needed. False implication, she said, is a matter for trial. Nobody appeared for the complainant.
The narrow door of revision
The petition was filed in 2016, so the Code of Criminal Procedure still governs it, in view of Section 531 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. The court cited Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander on the scope of revision.
Revision corrects a patent error of law or jurisdiction. It can be invoked where a finding rests on no evidence or material evidence is ignored.
For the charge stage, the judge turned to Section 227 and Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal. A judge may sift and weigh evidence only to see whether a prima facie case exists. Where the material gives rise to some suspicion but not grave suspicion, the accused may be discharged.
She also cited Sajjan Kumar v. CBI and Dipakbhai Jagdishchandra Patel v. State of Gujarat. A strong suspicion suffices to frame a charge, the latter says, but it must rest on material that can be translated into evidence at trial.
A name from the village is not evidence
The only material linking Mr Shah to the killing was the supplementary statement of 29 September 2012. In it, the court noted, the complainant said he had learnt the name at his own level and from his village. He did not say who told him, and no such person was examined.
Section 60 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, requires oral evidence to be direct. The court relied on Kalyan Kumar Gogoi v. Ashutosh Agnihotri, which holds that hearsay is inadmissible. The statement was therefore not material that could be translated into evidence at trial.
Even at face value, it did not show that the complainant had personal knowledge of Mr Shah’s presence. It could not found a strong suspicion. The complainant had identified Yogesh by photograph and again at the police station, but nothing showed he identified Mr Shah at any stage.
The approver left no room
The prosecution’s own material, the judge held, excluded Mr Shah. The FIR said Rajiv came with two companions. The investigation identified them as Yogesh and Bharat, and the approver’s statement under Section 164 fully accounts for both.
“there is no room for a fourth person” (para 17)
Mr Shah could have been a companion only if one of those two was absent, the court said. No such material was collected or placed before the trial court. The impugned order noted that the approver’s statement had been recorded but never considered its contents.
That was a case of material evidence being ignored, which is a recognised ground for revision. The conspiracy charge had no foundation either. The approver said Rajiv struck suddenly while they were drinking, and nothing connected Mr Shah to the alleged motive.
A charge framed mechanically
The trial court referred only in general terms to the police record and the supplementary statement. It did not ask whether the statement rested on personal knowledge, and did not discuss the approver or the co-accused’s disclosure statements. It even recorded the Additional Public Prosecutor as arguing that no ground for a charge existed.
Those were evidently the defence submissions. The court held that framing a charge in this way amounted to acting as:
“a post office of the prosecution” (para 19)
What six witnesses said after the charge
Six prosecution witnesses were examined in Mr Shah’s presence before the stay. The investigating officer, SI Ashok Kumar, admitted that apart from the supplementary statement no incriminating material came on the file against him. He said Mr Shah was found innocent in investigation and that the complainant did not identify him on 20 February 2014.
The complainant named Mr Shah in his examination-in-chief. In cross-examination he admitted he first saw him after the occurrence, when police produced him in court. He said his sister-in-law had learnt of the presence from the village, and she had not disclosed who told her.
He also claimed Raghu had told him by phone that Rajiv, Alok Shah and Joginder were sitting with him. Another brother, PW-6 Shiv Nath, said the complainant had told him of Mr Shah’s presence. Both versions were put to them as omissions from earlier statements.
The court called these improvements wholly inconsistent with the supplementary statement. The source of Mr Shah’s name, it said, remains unknown to this day. The complainant’s later denial that Bharat was present came after the charge, and he did not see the killing.
Naming an accused for the first time in court, after seeing him in custody, has little value, the judge held. She distinguished Sajjan Kumar, where witnesses claimed to have seen the accused personally. Here the defect was not delay alone but the inadmissible nature of the material.
She stressed that Mr Shah moved against the charge order without delay. The court was testing the legality of that order, not discharging him after a trial.
Order
The court did not examine the plea of old enmity, the plea that Mr Shah was away from Punjab, or the case diary entries. It found that the material gave rise at best to a suspicion founded on hearsay, contradicted by the prosecution’s own material. Calling on him to face trial for murder would be:
“an abuse of the process of the Court” (para 23)
The revision petition was allowed. The order of 12 July 2016 was set aside so far as it relates to Mr Shah, and the charges under Sections 302 and 120-B of the IPC were quashed. He was discharged and his bail and surety bonds, if any, were discharged.
The court made clear that nothing in the judgment expresses any opinion on the case against the co-accused Bharat alias Pandit, a proclaimed offender. The record of the trial court was ordered to be sent back forthwith, and a connected application to place documents on record was allowed.