Justice V. Aggarwal Punjab & Haryana HC PLEA DISMISSED A company wanted its former CFOback in custody
[ Punjab and Haryana High Court ]

Filing cases is not a bail breach: Punjab and Haryana HC refuses DLF plea to cancel ex-CFO bail

Justice Vikram Aggarwal held that petitions filed in the Supreme Court and three High Courts were legal remedies, not a breach of the conditions on which DLF former finance chief got bail in the Rs 311 crore extortion case.

DLF Limited told the Punjab and Haryana High Court that its former finance chief was using other courts to leak its secrets and frighten its witnesses. On 13 November, Justice Vikram Aggarwal refused to cancel his bail. Going to court, the judge held, is not a breach of bail conditions.

The man is Ramesh Sanka, accused in a Gurugram FIR of threatening to leak DLF’s confidential data to extort Rs 311 crore. The judge accepted that he appears to have the tendencies of a blackmailer and is certainly not a saint. That still did not justify sending him back to custody.

Rs 311 crore demand, then a bail order

FIR No. 253 of 8 August 2024 was registered at Police Station DLF Phase 1, Gurugram, on DLF’s complaint. It invokes Sections 381, 385, 409 and 506 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 66 of the Information Technology Act, 2000. Mr Sanka was arrested on 3 January 2025.

He joined DLF as Chief Financial Officer on 1 June 2004, became Group CFO, and later headed DLF Cyber City Developers Limited as Managing Director. He left on 2 July 2014. DLF says his senior post gave him free access to its data, books and records, and that Clause 11 of his appointment letter bound him to confidentiality.

The FIR alleges he threatened to misuse and leak that data unless he was paid Rs 311 crore. A coordinate bench granted him regular bail on 9 December 2025, after about 11 months in custody.

That bail order noted that the FIR came long after his employment ended in 2014 and rested on emails he had sent. He called them reminders about advisory fees, and the prosecution called them threats. Whether they amounted to extortion, the bench said, could be decided only at trial.

The bench also recorded that custodial interrogation was complete. The devices had been seized and examined, the charge sheet was filed, and 15 witnesses were cited. The State had not shown that any recovery remained.

The bench also rejected the idea that his other cases were a bar. Relying on Maulana Mohd. Amir Rashadi, it said criminal antecedents alone cannot defeat bail. A court must look at the accused’s role and at risks such as flight from the jurisdiction.

The conditions barred him from influencing, threatening or intimidating the complainant, the prosecution witnesses or anyone acquainted with the case, and from tampering with evidence. If he held any confidential data of the company, he was not to misuse it. He also could not leave the country without the trial court’s permission.

A string of cases in four courts

After his release, Mr Sanka went to court repeatedly. On 3 June 2026 he filed an application in the Supreme Court, in an appeal brought by SEBI, annexing emails, circulars and transfer and lease deeds. He also filed cases in the Delhi, Telangana and Madras High Courts, again with such documents attached.

Some of those cases are pending and others have been decided. The Telangana and Delhi High Courts had observed that the litigation was a private vendetta, and that he was settling personal scores under the guise of public interest. One Delhi petition has not been registered and remains in objections.

The State of Haryana filed a reply saying five other FIRs stand against him. Two laptops, a mobile phone and a hard disk were seized when he was arrested. A lab report of 21 August 2025 showed the extracted data, which the police said appeared to contain DLF’s confidential records.

The State added that a supplementary charge sheet would follow once the data was analysed. Its written reply said the facts warranted reconsidering bail. At the hearing, though, it gave only the factual position.

What DLF and Mr Sanka argued

Mr R.S. Cheema, Senior Advocate, led for DLF. He argued that the bail conditions had never been challenged, and that the string of cases was meant to induce, threaten and intimidate DLF and its witnesses. DLF said 32 lakh digital files were recovered from his hard disk, which is why specific conditions were imposed.

DLF called the intimidation a new kind, using data he held because of his post. It pointed out that Mr Sanka told the Delhi High Court he was a whistleblower. Even if some data is in the charge sheet, it argued, a final report is not a public document.

On the Supreme Court application, DLF said he was not even a party to the SEBI matter. The application itself, it said, stated in so many words that he held the data by virtue of his employment with DLF. It also said cases were being filed but not listed, only to intimidate.

Mr Ashok Aggarwal, Senior Advocate, appeared for Mr Sanka. Cancellation is an extreme measure, he said, and availing legal remedies can never be misuse of bail. The documents he used are also part of the final report, which includes 32 lakh pages of emails, so nothing confidential was leaked.

He said Mr Sanka resigned on 2 July 2014 and, on DLF’s own allegations, had no control over any data after that date. Using documents to file a writ petition is not misuse of confidential data, he argued. DLF had not shown how it was prejudiced.

He added that the supplementary charge sheet was filed without the prior permission of the court concerned. Even on conviction, he said, a sentence beyond one year was unlikely in a case triable by a Judicial Magistrate First Class. Mr Sanka had already spent about 11 months in custody.

The Rs 311 crore, he said, is a legal claim for job work done after he left office. DLF, he said, filed the FIR to pressure him.

Neither the bail order nor the petition, he said, specified which data was misused or was missing from the final report. Both sides cited Supreme Court rulings. DLF relied on Saurav Das and Gulabrao Baburao Deokar, among others. Mr Sanka cited Dolat Ram, Deepak Yadav and Gurcharan Singh, among others.

Cancelling bail versus revoking it

Justice Aggarwal began with Dolat Ram v. State of Haryana. Very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are needed to cancel bail already granted, it held. The illustrative grounds include interfering with the course of justice, evading it, abusing the concession, or a possibility of absconding.

He then turned to the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Abhimanue v. State of Kerala. It separates two things. Bail may be cancelled when the accused violates a condition, while an order granting bail can be revoked if it is perverse or illegal.

That ruling listed circumstances for cancellation, among them misusing liberty through other criminal activity, interfering with the investigation, tampering with evidence and threatening witnesses. The Supreme Court called the list illustrative, not exhaustive.

The judge also cited the three-judge bench in Deepak Yadav v. State of Uttar Pradesh. A court has inherent power to cancel bail even without supervening circumstances, it said, for instance where the bail order ignored relevant material.

The circumstances it listed include a bail order that took irrelevant material into account, overlooked the accused’s influential position against witnesses, or ignored his past record. Others are untenable grounds, serious discrepancies, charges too grave for bail, and an order that is whimsical or perverse.

That ruling recalled Prakash Kadam, which holds there is no absolute rule that bail can be cancelled only for likely misuse. The gravity of the offence and the accused’s position also count.

A question about conditions, answered no

The court framed the question for decision in these words:

“whether respondent No.2 can be said to have violated the conditions of bail warranting its cancellation” (para 22)

The answer, Justice Aggarwal wrote, was definitely in the negative. Apart from the litigation, no other action by Mr Sanka had been brought to the court’s notice. All the petitions had been perused, and they alleged, among other things, tax evasion and other violations by DLF.

Resorting to legal remedies cannot by any stretch be called a violation of the bail conditions, the judge held. Nor does it amount to inducing, threatening, intimidating or influencing DLF or the prosecution witnesses.

He added that Mr Sanka is yet to face trial, and the petitions he filed will be tried by courts of competent jurisdiction. No opinion could be formed on the truth of the FIR or of his cases against DLF.

On the weight of the remedy sought, the judge wrote:

“cancellation of bail is a very drastic measure” (para 27)

It should not be resorted to mechanically, the court said. Having gone through the FIR, the bail order, the petitions and the arguments, it found no case for cancellation at this stage.

Order

The petition under Section 483(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 was dismissed as devoid of merit on 13 November 2026. It had been reserved on 14 October 2026. Pending applications were disposed of.

The regular bail granted on 9 December 2025 in the coordinate bench’s order was not cancelled. The trial is pending in the court of a Judicial Magistrate First Class.