Bombay HC opens its own case on Sungrace Mafatlal marks registered to a dead applicant
Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan dismissed the grandson rectification petition as time-barred, then issued notices on his own motion because the 2017 registration went to an applicant dead since 2013. Replies are due on 15 January 2027.
In 2017 the Trade Marks Registry granted two registrations for the SUNGRACE MAFATLAL device marks in the name of Madhuri Mafatlal. She had died in July 2013, and the Registry had been told so in December 2015. On 19 November the Bombay High Court dismissed her grandson’s petition as time-barred, then started its own proceedings over that registration.
Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan held that Varun Atulya Mafatlal could not reset the clock on a claim his late father never pursued. He then issued notice on the court’s own motion to the current owner, an earlier recorded owner and the estate of the dead applicant.
Applied for in 2011, granted in 2017
Madhuri Mafatlal applied for the Class 24 mark on 7 January 2011 and the Class 25 mark on 19 July 2011. Registration certificates came on 5 May 2017 and 4 August 2017, in her name.
She died on 15 July 2013 and is said to have made a will on 6 February 2012. Her son Ajay, said to have died on 22 August 2015, is said to have made one on 5 August 2013. Neither will is probated or sought to be probated.
Another son, Atulya, died in September 2022. His son Varun is the petitioner, and Madhuri also had three daughters: Malavika Taktawala, Gayatri Jhaveri and Kunti Shah.
Two transfers in eight weeks
Malavika says Madhuri left the marks to Ajay, and Ajay left them to her and Gayatri. On 11 December 2015 she filed two applications to be recorded as subsequent proprietor, with the Madhuri will, death certificates and an undertaking from Gayatri.
The undertaking mentions an Ajay will but leaves its date blank, and the Ajay will itself was not produced. The judgment records that nobody can show any order on those 2015 applications.
On 11 May 2018 Malavika applied again, this time with a photocopy of the Ajay will. The Registrar recorded her as proprietor on 5 July 2018, with no notice to the relatives.
The next day she assigned both marks to Shree Vallabh Chandak for Rs 9 lakh each. He applied on 12 July 2018 and was recorded as proprietor on 17 September 2018.
The grandson’s case
Varun sought to expunge the entries in favour of Malavika and Chandak and to restore Madhuri as proprietor. He said Chandak was a mere family licensee who took the marks clandestinely, against an oral family settlement that barred alienation outside the family.
Mr Veerendra Tulzapurkar and Mr Ashish Kamat, Senior Advocates, argued for him. They said a right to apply under Section 57 is distinct from a right to sue, and that fraud and concealment postponed limitation under Section 17 of the Limitation Act until he learnt of the entries in August 2023.
They added that the title rests on unprobated wills, that Suit 685 was suppressed from the Registrar, and that no notice went to the heirs. He filed on 13 December 2023, and applied for condonation of 557 days’ delay on 2 July 2025, after Chandak raised limitation.
The Register, the wills and the Rules
Varun’s counsel also attacked the process. Section 213 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, they said, bars recognising rights under an unprobated will, and the executors never gave the assent the Act requires.
They said Rule 75 lets only a person entitled to a mark apply for assignment, and Rule 76 of the 2017 Rules needs a certified copy of the original instrument. The Registrar acted, they said, without notice, a speaking order or any inquiry into doubts.
Chandak answered that Section 213 binds courts and the Registrar is not one. Under Section 45 of the Trade Marks Act and Rule 77, he said, the Registrar may call for proof only where reasonable doubt arises.
The judge framed four questions: whether Varun is a person aggrieved, whether the petition is delayed beyond condonation, whether the entries were made without due process, and whether the court should act on its own motion.
What Chandak and Malavika argued
Mr Sharan Jagtiani, Senior Advocate for Chandak, said limitation had to be decided first. The right to apply accrued when the entry was made on 17 September 2018, he said, and Varun inherits his father’s clock.
He said Varun is a proxy for Mafatlal Industries, which belongs to a different branch of the family and had sent Chandak a legal notice on 26 February 2015. He added that Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules is directory and that Chandak is a bona fide assignee for value.
Mr Nikhil Kumar Rungta, for Malavika, said she believed in good faith that she held title under the wills. She was never in business, he said, and had been guided by Chandak and a broker. The Registrar did not appear or file anything.
Locus, and why it did not help
The judge first held that Varun is a person aggrieved under Section 57. As Madhuri’s grandson, and with the marks built on the family name, he was not an interloper, and the term is to be read liberally.
He relied on Hardie Trading, (2003) 11 SCC 92, and rulings in Infosys, V.R. Holdings and Toshiba. Whether the oral family arrangement Varun pleads is true, he said, is a matter of evidence to be tested.
But whether he can pursue a claim his father left alone, the judge said, is a question of limitation. The court decided it against him.
A claim that died with Atulya
Article 137 gives three years from when the right to apply accrues. Time began on 5 July 2018 and 17 September 2018, when entries were made in a public register, and expired in July and September 2021, while Atulya was alive.
Under Section 2(a)(ii) of the Limitation Act, an applicant includes a person through whom the applicant derives the right. Varun derives his right from Atulya, the court held, so his right cannot exceed his father’s.
Section 16 did not help, because time had started and run before Atulya died. Section 9 says that once time runs, later disability does not stop it. The judge rejected the idea of
“ever-greening of limitation with every succeeding generation” (para 33)
Siblings in court, a register in public
The judge found it unlikely that Atulya did not know. His siblings were suing one another, including Suit 685 filed by Malavika and Gayatri in this court, and Atulya was among those in litigation.
The Registrar had advertised Madhuri’s applications on 12 December 2016 and 13 March 2017, and the renewals in 2020. Atulya could have objected or searched the Register on any of those occasions.
The record also shows 21 licence agreements between Madhuri’s children and Chandak’s entities from 1998 to 2020. Varun himself, the judge noted, says he learnt of the entries from the neighbouring Arvind Mafatlal family in the same bungalow.
On fraud, the judge held that Section 17 postpones limitation only until discovery with reasonable diligence. Atulya, he said, could have discovered it, and his silence amounted to acquiescence and waiver. The condonation application failed.
A registration in the name of the dead
The petition could have ended there, but the judge said the record demanded a look at the Registrar’s conduct. Section 57(4) lets the High Court rectify the register on its own motion, and its basis is the integrity of the Register.
Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules, and Rule 61 of the 2002 Rules before it, deal with an applicant who dies before registration. The Registrar may substitute the successor in interest, but only on proof of death and proof of transmission.
Chandak argued the rule is only enabling. The judge rejected that, calling it
“a power coupled with a duty” (para 49)
Nothing showed that proof of succession was examined or that anyone was substituted. He called the answer that registration relates back to the 2011 filing date disingenuous, because it would let any registration issue in a dead person’s name.
The wills and the Class 25 mark
The judge said the Registrar could have called the executors to confirm succession, given the missing Ajay will and the blank date in Gayatri’s undertaking. Gayatri is a named executor of the Madhuri will.
The Madhuri will lists only the Class 24 mark, and describes it as already registered although registration was then pending. The Class 25 mark does not seem to appear in it at all, the judge noted, so it is unclear how Ajay could have left it to Malavika to assign.
Malavika admits she received royalties and Rs 9 lakh a mark, though she says she knows nothing of business. In para 51 the judge put it plainly that
“A dead person cannot sustain an application.” (para 51)
Order
The petition and the condonation application are dismissed as barred by limitation, without any finding on title or on the wills. The court is taking up suo motu rectification of the registration from scratch, including deletion of Madhuri’s name.
Chandak, Malavika and Madhuri’s estate, through the two executors named in her will, must show cause why the 2017 registration should not be cancelled. They must also explain how the Class 25 mark could have passed to Malavika, and justify relying on the two wills.
They must also show cause why the statutory effect of registration should not be stayed in the meantime. Replies by affidavit are due by 15 January 2027, which the judge said is nearly two months against the one month Rule 100 requires.
The Registry will send the judgment to the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks. A senior officer who has not handled the case must study the files from 2011 and file an affidavit by 15 January 2027.
The affidavit must explain how the Registry acted and whether it has a manual for applicants who die before grant. It must also give figures for registrations granted to dead persons in the past ten years.
The Registry of the High Court will register a new suo motu Commercial Miscellaneous Petition, listed for directions on 20 January 2027. The Succession Act questions on the wills are left open.