Justice S. Kumar Justice M.Y. Wani J&K and Ladakh HC BAIL REFUSED UAPA bail appeal dismissed;trial to be expedited
[ Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court ]

Jammu and Kashmir HC refuses UAPA bail after four and a half years in jail in Kakapora killing

A Division Bench held the Section 43D(5) bar attracted against Younis Mushtaq Bhat, who is charged under Sections 18 and 39 of the UAPA, found he had not served even half the maximum sentence, and asked the trial court to expedite the case.

Younis Mushtaq Bhat has been in custody since 23 April 2022, more than four and a half years. On 18 November the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh at Srinagar refused him bail in the Kakapora railway-station firing case, holding that the UAPA bar on bail still applies.

The judgment was written by Justice Mohd Yousuf Wani for a Division Bench with Justice Sanjeev Kumar. It was reserved on 13 November and pronounced in full on 18 November.

The bench upheld the Special Court order of 17 November 2025 and dismissed the appeal. It also asked the trial court to expedite the main case.

A shooting at Kakapora railway station

The case began on 18 April 2022, when police at Kakapora in Pulwama received information that unknown terrorists had fired on police personnel at the railway station. Head Constable Surinder Singh died on the spot, and Sub-Inspector Dev Raj was injured and later died on 23 April 2022.

FIR 29 of 2022 was registered at Police Station Kakapora. Four empty pistol cartridges were seized from the spot.

How the investigation reached the appellant

According to the prosecution, CCTV footage obtained from the railway authorities led to several suspects, including Mr Bhat. It says he first denied involvement, then admitted it when shown the footage, and was arrested.

The prosecution also relies on his disclosure before an Executive Magistrate. In it, he said a co-accused, Mukhtar Ahmad Bhat, took him on a motorcycle to the station and fired on two Railway Protection Force personnel, and that he was told to keep the motorcycle running.

The challan named four accused. Two of them, Mukhtar and Riyaz Ahmad Dar, were said to have joined terrorists and could not be arrested, so proceedings under Section 299 of the Code were started against them.

Mr Bhat was charged under Sections 18 and 39 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act on 27 December 2022. By the date of the bail order, the prosecution had examined 17 of its 42 listed witnesses.

What the appellant argued

Adil Pandit, his counsel, said Mr Bhat was falsely implicated and that no evidence had been collected or led at trial on the conspiracy charge. He pointed to the absence of any recovery from him or at his instance, and said the so-called confession had no value without a recovery.

He told the court that co-accused Tawheed Bashir Bhat was discharged of the Section 18 and 39 charges on similar allegations and was later bailed on 23 July 2024 under Section 13 of the Act.

The appellant also argued that he had developed ailments in jail, including a cardiac problem, and that long detention violated Article 21. About half the witnesses were still to be examined, he said, so the statutory bar should give way.

He relied on the Supreme Court in Union of India v. K A Najeeb, where bail was granted after five years in custody.

He also cited NIA v. Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali and Gurvinder Singh v. State of Punjab.

What the Union Territory answered

Mohsin Qadri, Senior AAG, said the accusation was prima facie true on the evidence gathered and led so far. He said the appellant was traced through CCTV footage and had admitted his role on being confronted with it.

The disclosure, he said, was corroborated by prosecution witnesses 5, 31 and 34. Witness 34 had told the Magistrate, and later the trial court, that the appellant revealed the facts to him after the attack.

The seized CCTV footage, listed at item 20 of the challan, would be proved at trial through an RPF witness yet to depose, he added.

The Section 43D(5) hurdle

The bench began with the statute. Section 43D(5) bars bail for an accused charged under Chapters IV and VI of the Act if the court, on the case diary or the police report, finds reasonable grounds to believe the accusation is prima facie true. Sections 18 and 39 fall in those chapters.

The court held that an accused must first clear this bar before bail can be considered under the ordinary provisions, Sections 437 and 439 of the old Code, now Sections 480 and 483 of the BNSS. It said the restrictions are in addition to those general rules.

On the meaning of the test, the court said the phrase cannot be read to mean proved. It is:

“something more than mere suspicion/conjectures” (para 11)

The expression, it added, means something short of proof, and what is prima facie true in one case may not be so in another. A bail court, it said, is not to hold a preliminary trial or weigh guilt or innocence.

Three witnesses tip the balance

The court found the bar justifiably attracted on the evidence collected and led so far. On the statements of witnesses 5, 31 and 34, it said, it had reason to believe at this early stage that the accusation against the appellant is prima facie true.

It rejected the argument that the case rested on surmise. That contention carried no weight at this stage of the trial, the bench said, and the trial court had no need to conduct a mini trial.

The bench also took support from the Supreme Court in Jalaluddin Khan v. Union of India (2024). It reproduced the passages that set out the eight Watali propositions, including that the material is to be read as a whole, taken as it is, and without a detailed look at its merits.

Four and a half years, but not enough

The appellant’s plea was the length of his custody. The court accepted that an accused has a fundamental right to a speedy trial under Article 21, but said:

“a balance needs to be struck” (para 32)

between the interests of the State and society and those of the accused. It found no fault in the way the Special Court distinguished K A Najeeb on the facts.

The court also looked at the sentence. Section 18 carries imprisonment up to life, and four and a half years in custody is less than one-half, let alone two-thirds, of the maximum.

That meant he could not claim bail under Section 479 of the BNSS, read with Section 6 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, which deals with the portion of maximum sentence served. The court also set out general bail principles for offences punishable with death or life, including that bail is the exception there.

Order

The appeal is dismissed and the Special Court order of 17 November 2025 stands. The bench said its observations were made only for deciding the appeal and are not to prejudge the merits of the case.

The trial court is requested to expedite the trial in the main case. The judgment was marked as speaking and approved for reporting.