Justice C.M. Poonacha Karnataka HC DEPORTATION BARRED Citizenship must be decidedfirst
[ Karnataka High Court ]

Karnataka HC bars deportation of man held as Bangladeshi until his citizenship claim is decided

Justice C.M. Poonacha held that the Foreigners Regional Registration Officer sent a Bengaluru businessman to a holding centre on the day of his arrest without testing his Indian papers, and that nationality is for a Foreigners Tribunal.

A Bengaluru scrap trader was picked up by police on 5 March, handed to the immigration office and ordered into a holding centre, all in one day. The order named him as a Bangladeshi called Md Rahim Howladar. He says he is Abdul Rahim, an Indian born in Delhi, with a passport and a voter card to show for it.

On 13 November the Karnataka High Court barred his deportation until the authorities decide his nationality after giving him a fair hearing. Justice C.M. Poonacha did not decide whether he is Indian. He held that nobody had yet decided it in the way the law requires.

The ruling turns on the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, and the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025. It is the High Court’s reasoned order on a movement restriction passed under them.

Picked up in a drive against illegal immigrants

The first petitioner, Abdul Rahim, is 47. His nephew, Jahidul Islam, is the second petitioner and represents him, as the uncle is in the holding centre. Both say they are Indian citizens.

Mr Rahim says he was born on 14 April 1979 at New Seemapuri, Delhi, and moved to Bengaluru in 2014. He runs a waste management and scrap trading proprietorship, AR Enterprises, from Kudlu, and lives with his wife and a six-month-old child.

On 5 March, officials of the Parappana Agrahara police station took him into custody on instructions from the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Electronic City Division. It was part of a drive to identify illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. He told them he was an Indian citizen and offered his documents.

The same day, the Foreigners Regional Registration Officer, or FRRO, passed a movement restriction order. It referred Md Rahim Howladar to the Utile Foundation in Kothanur and said he would not move out until his repatriation, as he might disappear and indulge in undesirable activities.

A habeas petition and a second writ

Mr Rahim first filed a habeas corpus petition, WP (HC) No. 40/2026. When it came up, the State produced the FRRO order. The High Court disposed of it on 17 April and left him free to challenge that order.

He did so in this writ petition under Article 226. On 6 July, the court restrained the authorities from deporting him and asked them to obtain details of a criminal case pending against him in Allahabad.

The 2012 conviction in Ghaziabad

That case dates from before he moved south. A Ghaziabad sessions court convicted him in 2012 under Section 14-A(b) of the Foreigners Act, 1946, on the allegation that he was a Bangladeshi named Abdul Rahim, son of Shah Jamal, from Bagerhat. His appeal, Criminal Appeal No. 2509/2012, is pending in the Allahabad High Court.

That court admitted the appeal on 6 July 2012 and released him on bail. It recorded that the maximum sentence was four years’ rigorous imprisonment, and ordered half the fine to remain unrealised. Justice Poonacha noted that it did not stay the conviction.

Mr Rahim argued that this meant an executive order could not take back the liberty a court had given him. He also raised double jeopardy under Article 20(2).

What each side argued

Clifton D. Rozario appeared for the petitioners. He called the order arbitrary and passed without an adequate chance to put the case, and said an executive order could not undo bail granted by a court.

Additional Solicitor General K. Aravind Kamath appeared for the State and the FRRO. He argued that Mr Rahim is a Bangladeshi using forged or fabricated documents, so the measures in Section 7 of the 2025 Act need not even be considered. The petition, he said, should fail on that ground alone.

The birth certificate that did not add up

The FRRO’s counter affidavit attacked the birth certificate. It said the Guru Gobind Singh Government Hospital, shown as the place of birth, was set up only in December 1995, and had no record of a birth in 1979.

The affidavit added that Delhi’s municipal corporation had no record of the death certificate of Mr Rahim’s father. It said the registration number on that certificate does not exist.

It also pointed to two birth certificates. The one filed in the habeas case showed registration on 24 August 2001 and issue on 18 March 2026. The one filed in this petition showed registration on 27 September 2019 and issue on 31 March 2026, under a different registration number.

The court compared the two in a table. Name, date of birth, hospital, parents’ names and address were the same in both. They had simply been applied for on different dates, it said. The hospital point, by itself, could not defeat the petition.

Nine documents and a 2005 voter card

Mr Rahim relied on much more than the birth certificate. The court listed a passport issued on 20 June 2018, a voter identity card issued on 5 December 2005, an Aadhaar card, a PAN card and a Delhi driving licence issued in 2010.

The list continued with an Udyam registration for AR Enterprises, a GST registration of 2023, a Bengaluru municipal identity card and his father’s death certificate. The FRRO’s affidavit said the voter card was not found in the electoral database, and called the secondary documents tainted by the fraudulent primary ones.

The court did not accept that. It noted that the voter card was the earliest document and that a passport is issued after a process of verification. The papers, it said, show that Mr Rahim has lived in India for a long period and consistently claimed to be a citizen.

Late registration of the birth certificate, beyond two years, could not be the sole basis for deciding the case either, since other documents had been produced. The court gave the same answer to the claim that the other papers were all tainted.

On those facts, the judge held, the authorities should have offered him an opportunity. A fair process on his claim to citizenship by birth was needed before any order seeking his removal from India.

The order that never mentioned the appeal

On the conviction, the court read the FRRO order closely. It does not mention the pending Allahabad appeal, so the conviction was not its basis. The order was passed on the premise that the man was a foreigner.

It also names him as Md Rahim Howladar, not Abdul Rahim. The Allahabad court had not ordered him confined in a detention centre. But the court added that this did not mean authorities under the 2025 Act could not detain a foreign national by an executive order.

A protocol started after the petition

The State relied on a communication of 2 May 2025 from the Union Home Ministry on deporting illegal Bangladeshi nationals and Rohingya. It tells States to hold a person who claims Indian citizenship in a holding centre while the home state or district verifies the claim.

The verifying State has 30 days to report. If none arrives, the FRRO may act to send the person back. The court noted that the communication mentions neither the 2025 Act nor the 2025 Order.

The record showed that the FRRO started this process only on 10 July 2026, after the writ petition was filed. It sent documents to the Delhi and Kolkata home departments, naming the man as Mr. Mohd Rahim Howladar, with a Bangladeshi identity number. No reply was placed on record.

What the 2025 law says about who decides

Justice Poonacha set out Section 7 of the Foreigners Act, 2025, published on 4 April 2025, and paragraph 8 of the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025. Section 7(2)(f)(ii) lets an authority require a foreigner to reside at a particular place.

The court noted that the repealed 1946 Act had a provision on determining nationality, and that nothing in the 2025 Act matches it. Section 16 of the new Act puts the burden on the person to prove he is not a foreigner.

Paragraph 16 of the 2025 Order is the key. It allows the Centre, a State, a district collector or a district magistrate to refer to a Foreigners Tribunal the question whether a person is a foreigner. The court read that as meaning a Tribunal decides it.

Fairness applies even to foreigners

The court began from settled ground. Article 19 rights belong to citizens only, but Articles 14 and 21 are available to all persons in India, including foreigners. It quoted the Supreme Court in Sabitri Dey, decided on 13 July 2026, that a person who may fail to prove citizenship is still owed a fair, reasonable and non-arbitrary process.

It also noted Hasan Ali Raihany, where the Supreme Court required reasons and a chance to represent before deportation. And it cited a Karnataka High Court Division Bench in Obinna Jeremiah Okafor, which held that a movement restriction order that curtails liberty needs minimum procedural fairness.

The court also reproduced two other High Court rulings. The Calcutta High Court in Amir Khan set aside a deportation done in hot haste and ordered the people brought back from Bangladesh. The Gujarat High Court in Rasidaben ordered a man released until the authorities heard his nationality case.

Hearing in court was not enough

The State argued that the writ petition was itself the opportunity to prove citizenship. It relied on Christopher Charles Kamolins, in which a coordinate bench said post-decisional representation and Article 226 review can satisfy natural justice.

Justice Poonacha distinguished it. That case involved an Australian citizen on an employment visa, where officials later found the documents behind the visa were fraudulent. He was served a Leave India notice during the visa period. The facts here were completely different.

Nothing on record showed that Mr Rahim was told, before 5 March, that he was alleged to be a foreign national. Nor had his documents been considered before the conclusion was reached.

The judge also noted that, apart from the 2010 Ghaziabad case, no criminal case was registered against him. The State had not alleged, and nothing showed, any national security concern.

The FRRO’s own review came too late

The FRRO had examined Mr Rahim’s documents, but only after the order and during the writ petition, as its affidavit showed. The court held that the 2025 Act does not give the FRRO the job of adjudicating that question.

It held that the adjudication in the affidavit was not as contemplated by the 2025 Act or Order. Nor did the order of 5 March adjudicate any of his documents.

The State insisted that the burden was on the petitioner. The court accepted that, citing Sabitri Dey and Okafor. But the burden, it held, does not excuse the process:

“a fair procedure is to be adopted before the petitioner is deported/removed from India” (para 76)

Residence restriction upheld, deportation barred

The court did not strike down the movement restriction itself. Section 7(2)(f)(ii) allows a residence requirement, it said, so the order was not without authority of law. The order refers him to the foundation and directs him not to leave, which the court did not treat as detention.

It left the nationality question open. Without the authorities starting proper steps and the petitioner having an adequate chance to answer them, the court said, it would not decide his nationality for the first time in a writ petition.

But the order said he could be repatriated only after an adjudication of nationality, and that had not been done in accordance with law. The authorities could proceed on their own conclusions, the court said, but only after giving him an adequate opportunity.

Order

The writ petition is disposed of. The authorities shall take the steps they consider necessary on the nationality of the first petitioner, as set out in the FRRO’s counter affidavit, after giving him an adequate opportunity in accordance with law, and as expeditiously as possible.

Until those steps are taken, the first petitioner shall not be repatriated or deported. The judgment does not quash the movement restriction order of 5 March 2026 or direct his release.